Genetic determinants and evolution of drug resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis in Vietnam : toward new diagnostic tools

Tuberculosis (TB) is one of the deadliest infectious diseases worldwide, mainly caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Multidrug resistant (MDR) and extensively drug resistant (XDR) TB are currently main challenges for TB control. In high MDR-TB burden countries like Vietnam, one of the main factors of drug resistant strain spread is the insufficient capacity of drug resistance detection. Besides, still little is known in these countries about the resistance to second line and pyrazinamide drugs (key drugs in the MDR-TB treatment) and the genetic determinants linked to these resistances. In this context, this work aimed to acquire knowledge on drug resistance in Vietnam and to understand how M. tuberculosis evolved from sensitive to highly drug resistance form by molecular analysis.260 clinical isolates collected in Vietnam between 2005 and 2009 were included. Various techniques and analyses were used: drug susceptibility testing (development of a test with a reduced turn-around time), spoligotyping and 24-MIRU-VNTR typing and gene sequencing. The data were analyzed by statistical and phylogenetic analyses.First, this work was focused on highly drug resistant M. tuberculosis clinical isolates and pyrazinamide resistance. A high proportion of quadruple first-line drug resistant isolates (resistant to isoniazid, rifampicin, streptomycin and ethambutol) have been characterized as pre-XDR and XDR isolates, belonging especially to Beijing family. The molecular analysis revealed also high proportion of drug resistant isolates carrying highly confident pyrazinamide resistance-associated mutations, particularly in MDR and quadruple resistant isolates and in Beijing family.Second, the genetic and phylogenetic analyses showed high diversity of mutation patterns within each family and each MIRU-VNTR cluster suggesting various evolutionary trajectories towards first and second-line drug resistance. The predominance of specific mutations and combinations of mutations associated with high level of resistance and low fitness cost suggests a cumulative effect of mutations and a role for epistasis in multiple-drug resistance acquisition. In addition, high frequency of fitness-compensatory mutations associated with rifampicin resistant mutations was detected in highly drug resistant isolates. These processes may drive the evolution of drug resistance in this sample and lead to a successful spread of highly drug resistant strains. It is worth noting that Beijing family was specifically linked to high-level drug resistance and low fitness cost mutations and to compensatory mutations.In conclusion, this work provides knowledge on the resistance to the first and second-line anti-TB drugs in clinical M. tuberculosis samples collected in Vietnam between 2005 and 2009. These data predict an evolution towards a more problematic situation in terms of drug resistance. First, because the Beijing family, which is currently invading Vietnam, is associated with highly drug resistance, mutations linked to high-level drug resistance and low fitness cost and compensatory mutations. Second, the high risk of pyrazinamide resistance in our sample challenges the efficacy and the use of this drug in MDR-TB treatment. Third, our data suggest an evolution of M. tuberculosis towards a higher potential of drug resistance because of a probable cumulative effect of drug resistant mutations and epistatic interactions. Since the samples under study were collected between 2005-2009, the next step is to test our hypotheses on a recent sampling. Finally, this study together with published data allowed making, for the first time, an inventory of the drug resistance associated mutations in M. tuberculosis isolates from Vietnam.