Typical and Atypical Development of Numerical Representation

How numerical information is represented? Recent studies have highlighted the prominent role of preverbal core knowledge systems for representing numerical quantities: the Object Tracking System (OTS) and the Approximate Number System (ANS; or analogue magnitude system). The former is general mechanism which allows individuals to track the spatio-temporal characteristics of the objects and its capacity is limited (3-4 items). The latter is a quantitative mechanism which entails the representation of each numerosity as a distribution of activation on the mental number line. In the present work we investigated several aspects of these two systems along with numerical and non-numerical estimation ability in typical and atypical development. In Study 1.1, we implemented an imitation task to investigate the spontaneous focusing on numerosity in 2 ½ year-old children. The results suggest that most of the children employed the analogue magnitude system when spontaneously encoding numerosity. The use of the analogue magnitude system may be related to both its low demanding of attentional resources and to the availability of other (non-numerical) quantitative cues which covariate with numerosity. In Study 1.2, 2 ½ year-old children completed a categorization task in order to investigate their ability in estimating numerical sets. Children’s estimations were independent from the visual characteristics of the stimuli (i.e. perimeter or density) within the OTS capacity. Conversely, the estimation of larger quantities (5-9 dots) was significantly affected by stimuli characteristics: in particular, the increase of perimeter with a constant density appears as the combination of visual characteristics which strongly increases the perceived numerosity. In Study 2, Preschoolers, Grade 1 and Grade 3 pupils had to map continuous, discrete and symbolic quantities. The results indicated that different mechanisms are involved in the estimation of continuous quantities with respect to numerical (discrete and symbolic) quantities. In Study 3, we devised a dual-task paradigm to investigate the relation between visual short term memory (VSTM) and subitizing. We found a striking correspondence between the number of elements retained in VSTM and the number of elements that can be subitized. In Study 4.1, children with developmental dyscalculia (DD) in comorbidity with a profile of Non-Verbal syndrome (NVS) and typically developing (TD) children completed a numerical comparison task. We found a specific deficit in the comparison of numerical quantities in DD-NVS children with respect to TD. In particular, the OTS capacity seems to be reduced in the DD-NVS group as compared to TD. In Study 4.2, children with developmental dyscalculia (DD) and typically developing (TD) children completed two number-line tasks. Children with DD displayed a less precise estimation of symbolic quantities, thereby suggesting a specific deficit in the number representation with respect to TD children. In Study 5, individuals with Down Syndrome (DS) and typically developing children matched for both mental (MA) and chronological age (CA) completed two numerical tasks in order to evaluate their ability to compare non-symbolic quantities (i.e. dots) and counting process. Kids with DS showed a specific deficit in comparing small quantities, within OTS capacity, with respect to both MA and CA matched kids. For the comparison of larger quantities, kids with DS displayed a performance similar to MA matched controls but lower as compared to CA matched controls. Finally, the counting ability appears similar between kids with DS and MA matched children.