White matter lesions in depression and Alzheimer's disease

Sm: Rao (1996) comments that subjects who had transient ischaemic attacks â€œ¿ do not appear to have been excludedâ€•from our magnetic resonance imag ing (MRI) study (O'Brien et a! , 1996), which showed an association between deep white matter lesions (DWML) and depression. There is nothing in our paper to suggest this. Indeed, subjects with a past history of stroke and transient ischaemic attacks were specifically excluded. We did find that subjects with depression had more vascular risk factors than controls or subjects with Alzheimer's disease. This is not surprising as an association between vascular disease and depression has long been recognised and has been confirmed by Baldwin & Tomenson (1995). However, we showed that even controlling for known vascular risk fac tors (either by excluding such subjects or by regres sion analysis), DWML were still significantly more common in depressed subjects, particularly those presenting with their first ever depression in late life. Interestingly, the latter finding has recently been replicated by Salloway et al(1996). However, as we state in our paper, this does not mean that these lesions do not represent vascular disease; it may be that depressed subjects are particularly liable to develop vascular changes in the brain, perhaps as a result of genetic susceptibility or some environmental factors. Rao's suggestion that periventricular lesions (PVL) involve vascular mechanisms simply because they are found commonly in patients with vascular dementia is unduly simplistic. Such an association does not imply cause. Moreover, there has been some good work looking at the pathological basis of white matter lesions, which clearly demonstrates that mild-to-moderate PVL (at least in non depressed subjects) have a pathogenesis that is quite distinct from that of DWML and is unlikely to be simply vascular in origin (e.g. Fazekes et a! , 1993). The recent demonstration that white matter lesions on MRI, hitherto felt to be fairly non specific features, can be separated into different types, which show particular associations with specific psychiatric disorders, is an exciting develop ment that may have importance in advancing our understanding of the pathophysiology of these illnesses. Attributing all such lesions to cerebrovas cular disease is no longer tenable. We are pleased that Rao agrees with us that the way forward is for prospective clinico-pathological studies to further elucidate the clinical, structural and biochemical correlates of such lesions. B@wwmi, R. C. & TOMENSON, B. (1995) Depression in later life. A comparison of symptoms and risk factors in early and late onset cases. BritishJournalofPsychiatry, 167, 649â€”652. F@. miun, F. , Cim.saai, R. , OFFENBACHER, H. , ci al(1993) Patho logical correlates of incidental MRI white matter hyper intensities. Neurology, 43, 1683â€”1689. O'BRIEN,J. T. , DESMoND, P., Auas, D. , et a! (1996) A magnetic resonanceimagingstudy of whitematter lesionsin depression and Alzheimer's disease. British Journal of Psychiatry, 168, 477-485. RAO, R. (1996) Pathogenesis of white matter lesions in Alzheimer's disease and depression (letter). British Journal of Psychiatry, 169, 114. SALLOWAY, S. , MALL0Y,P., KouN, R. , et a! (1996) MRI and neuropsychological differences in earlyand late-life onset geriatric depression. Neurology, 46, 1567â€”1574.