Question: Who was born first out of Giuseppe De Gaetano and Phil Phelps?
Sentence (from "Phil Phelps"): Phil Phelps( born May 1, 1979) is a Democratic member of the Michigan House of Representatives, elected in a special election in 2013 to replace Jim Ananich after he resigned his seat to replace John J. Gleason who was elected clerk of Genesee County in 2012.
Relevant evidence: Yes