response: I'm unaware if it is or not, but there have been scientific blinding wine tastings that contradict wine tasting reliability.
original_response: You could say so, however, results have surfaced that definitely tend to contradict the reliability of wine tasting.  Blind testing has identified many inconsistencies.
history: Is it true Wine tasting is a delicate art?
knowledge: Results contradicting the reliability of wine tasting in both experts and consumers have surfaced through scientific blind wine tasting, such as inconsistency in identifying wines based on region and price.