definiens: means any direct or indirect ( through the actions of another acting on Licensee ’s, its Affiliate ’s, or a Sublicensee ’s behalf or upon its or their instruction ) dispute or challenge, or any knowing, willful or reckless assistance in the dispute or ch allenge, of the validity, inventorship, ownership o r enforceability of any Patent Right or any claim the reof, or opposition or assistance in the opposition of the grant of any letters patent within the Patent Rights, or any disparagement of the Patent Rights or raising o f any issue of the Patent Rights ’ compliance with or sufficiency u nder applicable patent laws, regulations or adminis trative rules, in any legal or administrative proceedings i n a court of law, before the United States Patent a nd Trademark Office or other similar agency or tribunal in any j urisdiction, or in arbitration including, without l imitation, by reexamination, inter partes review, opposition, interference, post - grant revie w, nullity proceeding, preissuance submission, third party submission, derivation proc eeding or declaratory judgment action