Movie for Musicians

Rating: 10/10 (13 October 2019)

I noticed a lot of negative reviews and didn't get it. But, my wife thought it was okay and I thought it was great. I think the difference of opinion is that I'm a musician and producer. There are a lot of jokes and situations in this movie that will fall flat for those that aren't musicians. Things such as pausing recording during a train rolling by, people ignoring you when you're performing amazing songs, or family and friends talking and being preoccupied while you're performing a masterpiece- these are pretty accurate frustrations for musicians that are also pretty funny.
Jack, the lead, isn't the best songwriter but he is a good guy, music lover and idealist. What makes him the perfect vehicle for introducing Beatles music to the world is that he simply loves and admires great music so much, which is also the same reason for his frustrations- some people just don't get how intensely some feel about music, just like some don't get this movie. Ed Sheeran probably wasn't necessary, and him calling himself the greatest songwriter until Jack came along is ridiculous, especially in a movie made for musicians- he's only admired by people that no nothing about music, but even be had a few funny moments in the movie.
Overall, the whole movie is a vehicle to pay homage to the Beatles, music lovers and idealists. It performs very well in managing to pay respect in those regards. It is definitely a Danny Boyle movie, which are told in an innocent, simplistic and idealistic manner, which can seem oversimplified but also make the movie endearing. If you love the Beatles or are a musician, check this out - otherwise, there's probably another Fast and Furious out. You can bang your head against the wall while watching those gems.