A fine conclusion.

Rating: 8/10 (19 June 2006)

Many fans of the cinematic X-Men were against "X-Men: The Last Stand" before it was even released. This was, in large part, due to the non-involvement of original director Bryan Singer, and his replacement by studio director Brett Ratner. While Ratner is not a creative talent of Singer's skill, it's my opinion that most of the flaws in this production predate Ratner's involvement, as they mostly pertain to the scripting phase, conducted under the direction of studio executives and Matthew Vaughn. In any event, the flaws detract, but do not cripple the film.
Fans will always speculate about Singer's potential storyline, and, almost unanimously, will conclude it would have been superior. Leave that to other fans; the plotting of this film works quite well, although those who say the movie could have used another half-hour are quite accurate in saying so. The mutant cure plot and the Dark Phoenix story compliment each other suitably, and it all comes together for a terrific finale, including the finest superhero brawl ever filmed.
Arguably, the production's big flaw predates Ratner by two films: Halle Berry as Storm, who continues to prove anemic and a sour note. Berry's amplified role in X3 only serves to cast further light on this. Luckily, stalwarts like Hugh Jackman, Ian McKellen, and Patrick Stewart are on hand, as well as newcomers like Kelsey Grammar (who's the real McCoy, if I am to be allowed the pun) and Ellen Page (the third Shadowcat in as many films, but irresistible in the part). Famke Janssen has a tough role as the reimagined Phoenix, but, again, any problems with her most be accorded to the writers.
In sum, I think the X-franchise is in good standing. If nothing else, the stage is ripe for spin-offs focussing on Wolverine, a younger Magneto, and the younger X-Men like Shadowcat and Iceman. It's not as good as X2, but a commendable effort nonetheless.