Finally, a real comic-book movie

Rating: 8/10 (16 July 2000)

Movies based on comics characters tend to apologize. The film-makers often transmit an embarrassment to the screen, and like to throw little moments into the film that show us that they're not really taking it seriously, and they know how silly it all really is.
X-Men does not have those moments, thank god. This is a real adaptation of a superhero comic, by far the most faithful ever made. Anyone familiar with the comic will recognize the characters and situations presented here, and without apology or condescension.
Does that mean that only comics fans will enjoy it? Honestly, I don't think so, but I can't be sure. I was too overjoyed with the adaptation of characters I was familiar with. Even the good comic-to-film transfers have messed with the characters (Batman's rubber armor comes to mind).
The film has its problems, of course. There's very little time to develop all of the characters. Storm, in particular, gets short shrift in the screen time department. At 95 minutes, this is one economical piece of filmmaking. But at a time when even fluff like "Meet Joe Black" can clock in at three hours, this is actually very refreshing, and keeps "X-Men" from bogging down in the self-important philosophizing that the comic often indulges in.
As expected, Wolverine quickly takes center stage. Given that, the casting was vital, and fortunately, the ball was not dropped. Hugh Jackman IS Wolverine, to the point that it's impossible to see anyone else in the role. Similarly, Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen have now BECOME Professor Xavier and Magneto. I will not be able to see the comics characters without seeing these actors; they're that perfect. The award for most improved character goes to Rogue, whom I've always found irritating in the comic, but who is very nicely re-imagined here.
This is a great introduction, whose only real flaw is that it DOES feel somewhat like a mere introduction. Hopefully, the already-contracted sequels will flesh out this very promising beginning.