The Definitive Vietnam Combat Story

Rating: 10/10 (7 October 2002)

Unfortunately, "We Were Soldiers" followed "Saving Private Ryan" and "Blackhawk Down." Otherwise, it would have enjoyed more than its mostly-ignored 5-6 month theater run before being released in video. Apparently the public had overdosed on realistic depictions of combat and war stories based on real events and people. This is the only reason I can imagine for the "so-what?" public reaction to this fine film. First of all, Nam vets -- especially helicopter vets -- unanimously consider this to be the truest rendering of their war. Second, it's Mel Gibson's finest work; his delivery of Col. Moore's words, and the anguish reflected in his face following this watershed battle, move many of us to tears. There are numerous other notable performances. The inclusion of war's impact on wives and children made the women's roles significant, rather than cameos. Furthermore, the depiction of the NVA as (1) highly motivated and well led and (2) as human beings with families presents a more balanced view of war. Finally, the political messages are subtly delivered and do not detract from the main purpose of the movie, which is to tell the story of war. Well worth seeing, perhaps more than once.