It made be grateful

Rating: 9/10 (17 March 2002)

I went in with the bias of having read the book. And I loved the book. The film is remarkably faithful to the story, and I was impressed by Wallace's restraint. While visually very powerful, it could easily have employed more of the technological tricks so many directors are unable to resist. Instead, he relies on strong performances from his cast, and knew the story was truly extraordinary and did not need embellishments. Gibson is no Olivier, and there are other actors who could have done better. But Gibson gave it his all, and he did a fine job. I do think the film will likely miss with many who aren't familiar with the book. The bravery of the men and the ferocity of the battle, while all true, are truly unbelievable. And for those who are suspicious of movies celebrating the nobility and courage of American soldiers, this will be uncomfortable to view. It didn't make me squirm...it made me proud. It made me grateful.