Against the consensus.

Rating: 3/10 (16 March 2009)

Against the consensus, but hey! First of all, let me begin by informing you all that I have not read the graphic novel. I have no prior knowledge of these characters, or the story. I deliberately ignored all reviews about the film, and kept an open mind as I do regularly.
I'll start with the acting. Wilson was reasonably convincing in the role of Dan, as was Morgan in the role of Eddie Blake. Both actors played their parts well, and convinced me that they were super heroes for the duration. One performance, however, stood out. A straight mile above the rest was Jackie Earle Haley in the role of Rorschach. His acting was astounding, and I felt an attachment to this character by the end of the film. It was the only performance I feel that deserves anything in the form of high praise.
I am the belief that the story was unsuitable for the big screen. It felt almost as random and pointless as 'The Spirit', and I was equally bored and bewildered throughout. I'm all for a far fetched story, but Dr Manhattan's back story, and character as a whole seemed on a par with that of a five year old's art-class project. The story failed to command my attention, and I was furious with the way it ended.
Overall, I'm sure this film is excellent if you're a fan of the graphic novel. However, be warnedÂ… If you've never read it before, you're in for a shock; and it probably won't be a good one.