"Please, Leave Now."*

Rating: 10/10 (29 May 2017)

*Words of an Afghan villager to the American general.
That says it all. We should have never gone in the first place. They criticize Obama—at least obliquely—but I think Obama wanted no part of these wars that he didn't instigate. When he took office the military elite treated him like an ignorant child and I think Obama just said, "OK. I'll let you idiots own these completely failed wars." If you are still blaming Obama for these nightmares then you are a complete idiot or an amnesiac.
It isn't a very cinematic depiction of war but it could be the most realistic telling of how wars are fought that has ever been put on film. Of course, I'm not including documentaries and this would have been much better as a documentary. Just why this wasn't a documentary or why they didn't call General McCrystal by name seems like a mistake to me.
War isn't cool or sexy, the way it's portrayed in dung heaps like American Sniper films of that ilk that glorify killing and mayhem.
Our military leaders since WWII have been the very worst of our elite in America, even worse than our financial leaders who are thieving scoundrels with the morals of snakes. Our military leaders are blind half-wit unable to learn from their many, many mistakes over the past 70 years and almost every move they have made has been a mistake.
McCrystal was exactly the delusional creep that the reporter in the film calls out: "As an elected representative of the people of Germany it is my job to ensure that the personal ambitions of those who serve those people are kept in check. You have devoted your entire life, General, to the fighting of war and this situation in Afghanistan, for you, it is the culmination of all your years of training, all your years of ambition. This is the great moment of your life.
It's understandable to me that you should have, therefore, a fetish for completion to make your moment glorious. It is my job, however, to ensure that your personal ambitions are not entirely delusional and do not carry with them an unacceptable cost for everybody else."
Just what did our military elite think would be the result of our invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq? They couldn't give a straight answer to the American public and the Bush administration tip-toed around anything that hinted at predictions. They ridiculed reporters who asked them for predictions. Isn't a lack of predictions evidence of a lack of a plan?
So instead of any coherent strategy they gave us platitudes about facing evil. In the film before the General's big plan we get a rousing and moronic locker room speech reminiscent of Henry V and then a chaplain gives an even more moronic and insipid prayer.
(Perhaps you should begin by rereading the Rolling Stone article that shanghaied the career of the general. For the July 8, 2010 piece Google: rolling stone mcchrystal)