Way overrated

Rating: 5/10 (5 December 2005)

If one wants to learn about Johnny Cash they would learn much more by watching the documentary about Cash on PBS. After watching that, this movie just doesn't do it. Reese Witherspoon is no June Carter who was a splendid singer in her own right. Phoenix does a reasonable imitation of Cash but in no way does he capture either the personality or the unique voice of Cash. It is like watching the musicians on the Lawrence Welk show imitate Cash or any other great musician. No true fan of Johnny Cash would enjoy this movie.
It's what might be called a "poor man's Grand Ol' Opry." There are much better ways to spend one's money than watching this flick. After seeing all the rave reviews (by people who obviously were never Cash fans, I was sorely disappointed and wish I could have gotten a refund.