weak characters (spoilers ahead)

Rating: 7/10 (4 July 2003)

OK, I know this is a masterpiece and everything, and I agree that it
had great photography and special effects (the zooming in and
out), but the story itself was pretty dumb. More specifically, Scotty
was a really dumb detective, and he should have retired 20 years
before the beginning of the movie. His obsession with Madeline
and his need to reconstruct Judy (only to find out that the
reconstruction was originally a reconstruction anyway) are totally
unfitting and he just comes across as an aging pervert. There's a
lack of consistency throughout the movie, no matter how much one
chooses to suspend one's disbelief. Not impressive.