a poor poor remake of a good good film

Rating: 3/10 (10 June 2007)

it's so strange that i've seen very good ratings for this movie. i am pretty sure that these people didn't see the Spanish original film at all.
Besides, can some note the schizophrenic style of scoring ? there is NOT any relationship between the mood of the scenes and the random songs selected to play along with. That single fact takes away much more of the drama strengh of the film. How can these people not to note this ? If you are going to spend millions of dollars in copying a good movie you always take the risk of doing a vulgar and pretty much mediocre "copy"... but the fact is... the original movie was Spanish, not Hollywood. and most of the world will never notice.
sometimes its good not to be American