Initial opinion was 'Horrible!,' later upgraded to 'disappointing'

Rating: 6/10 (27 December 2008)

With the notable exception of Thomas Kretschmann, and possibly Bill Nighy, the cast just did not make convincing Nazis. There was nothing of the sinister rigidity and fear that could have really enhanced the triller aspect of the plot. I felt like I was watching a movie with an American and a bunch of Brits trying to play Nazis. The story, however, seemed to be a fairly accurate historical account of the events on which the movie is based. That I commend, although there really wasn't a convincing romantic element or memorable musical score that I think could have greatly added to the underlying story. I believe the movie could have been made ten times better by using a cast of unknowns, who at least were German. I had been waiting for this movie for a long time, and unfortunately, overall, I would have to say it was a disappointment.