Good film, but a "Cliffs Notes" version of the story.

Rating: 7/10 (24 March 2006)

It is hard to comment on a rich story, such as V for Vendetta, within a 1,000 words. It is a story of ideas, filled with rich language and subtle nuances. It has iconic imagery and liberal use of symbolism. It presents deep political arguments and moral ambiguity. The film captures most of these themes, but in a more compact and simplistic version. It is faithful to segments of the story, but drastically alters the course of the tale.
The acting is quite good, across the cast. Stephen Rea is a particular standout as Finch, the detective in pursuit of V. He is good man who has lost his way. He made choices that he thought were in the best interest of his society, but soon learns how wrong they were. Hugo Weaving is able to move beyond the limitations of a mask, using only voice and body language. Natalie Portman sports a dodgy accent, but conveys the innocence and growth of her character with skill. John Hurt provides a bit of irony, as he looms over video screens, like the Big Brother that tormented him in 1984. Stephen fry brings a touch of humor, some tragedy, and a large dose of humanity to the film.
The film mostly captures the themes of the source, that true power in a society derives from the people, not the government. Totalitarian states rule through fear, and when the populace learns that it has nothing to fear from its government, it is able to tear it down and replace it with something better. It mostly ignores anarchy, as a political concept, but does capture the feelings of euphoria that come over the populace, when they are freed of surveillance and control. It shows that labels like "terrorist" and "freedom fighter" depend greatly on which side of a conflict you are on.
Fans of the graphic novel will find the film a mixed bag: the basic themes are there, but the subtleties and depth is lacking. Those unfamiliar may find some of the ideas challenging, but worthy of discussion. The visuals are memorable and, generally, in service of the story. There is much greater depth than most recent "genre" works, but there is much room for improvement. The film builds to a stirring climax, albeit a simplistic one. This is definitely a film that stirs discussion, and is very courageous and timely.