So much more than I expected

Rating: 10/10 (2 August 2006)

I haven't read any of the graphic novels but, even if I had, accuracy to a novel is not what makes a film great it's irrelevant really. This is a great film because it made me want to come here and write about it and persuade others to watch it so I can discuss it with them. I love and watch films I have over 1200 DVDs. I have voted on a few films and thrown around a handful of 10s but commented on only 3 so that's how significant I think this film is.
This worked at the right level because it is a sum of it's parts it's not held up just by performances, story or visuals but a well mixed cocktail of all the elements. It gripped and entertained but made me question and think whilst caring about the characters. It's well paced and very well written. It is, of course, helped by being visually very good, having great dialogue and some good performances.
Best film I have seen in a good while.