Outstanding, Superior, Another "Citizen Kane"?

Rating: 10/10 (28 May 2006)

This is such a realistic portrayal of some of the events of Sept. 11, 2001 that it is difficult to evaluate this film as one does other movies. Yet, this is an artistic creation, and all decisions regarding script, cast, set, etc. were made for specific reasons by the director. I believe Paul Greengrass has achieved something never before in cinema--a truly compelling and gripping portrayal of actual events, without succumbing to Hollywood jargon or cliché or an overindulgence in sentiment, taste or reverence. I didn't realize until after watching this movie the first time that the cast includes people who portray themselves. While that lends a semblance of authenticity I don't think it would have been any less realistic with all professional actors. This is a movie that deserves respect and recognition because it succeeds as an outstanding film as well as a credible account of events. I doubt any other movies that portray the events of 9-11 will come close to achieving such a rare balance.