Entertaining but simplistic

Rating: 6/10 (3 March 2008)

Entertaining character study with terrific photography. But the writing and supporting performances can't match Day-Lewis's contribution.
The dramatic arc is relatively shallow for a 2.5 hour movie covering a 30 year time span and rival Paul Dano is borderline amateur. The third act is virtually unnecessary - after 15 years, none of the principal characters have changed.
Additionally, the impact of the climax is diminished by Daniel Plainview's previous murderous actions - there are no surprises after 150 minutes. Note to PT Anderson: a long runtime is not a substitute for complexity.