Rocky Pales in Contrast

Rating: 9/10 (16 February 2009)

I saw The Wrestler just after viewing Doubt, within about a week. I think what we have here are two ends of the spectrum, the non-action film vs. the action film, and I credit the Academy for recognizing both. It is nice to think, even trust, that Academy members have a broad view of what might be considered exceptional films. What the two films have in common is noteworthy acting. Give the edge to "The Wrestler", and I'll tell you why.
This is one heckuva piece of work, in every way films are measured. Mickey Rourke, as Randy the Ram, is totally believable as a fading wrestling star. Right from the beginning we see that his is not the life of a successful sports star. His painfully sad existence is evinced in scene after exhausting scene, sometimes with the people he has accumulated along the way as associates, and sometimes just as the camera trails along with him. And along the way we get a good feel for ins and outs of the gritty world of professional wrestling.
His colleagues in this effort all do great work (Marisa Tomei's strong performance is eclipsed by her knockout topless scenes - there aren't many +40 year old actresses that look THAT good) and lend an air of authenticity to the people with whom with he associates. There is only one over-the-top scene (overacting) in the film, that involving Randy's daughter (Evan Rachel Wood). Wood is good at all other moments.
There are really nice, even memorable, touches in this film. Some of the wrestling scenes are quite amazing; how do they not get hurt? Randy the Ram's fellow athletes and promoters lend authenticity throughout. Even the opening tableau of playbills, ticket stubs and photos from the Ram's past is smart stuff.
Rourke's physical demeanor alone is fascinating to study; you really can't take your eyes off him. It is hard to imagine another actor extant that could have performed this role as well. While the ending may not play well with some, I am not sure it could have been done any other way, successfully. But that is why you should see it; decide for yourself if this the logical ending for what is not at all just another sports film.
I give this film 3-1/2 stars.