A well crafted historically important and informative film

Rating: 10/10 (19 August 2006)

The historical reasons why the Irish republicans were fighting for the same end but could not agree on the methods, imparts important information for anyone who may be drawn into conflicts in other parts of the world. The film says that conflicts are never simple; it is essential to understand the history behind a conflict before deciding on any course of action, and then a great deal of thought must be given to any purposeful action. That seemed to relate to anywhere connected to the British empire and its mandate, because the British Empire seemed always to depart leaving another intractable problem in their wake. Innocent bystanders always get hurt in conflict and turmoil. Simply being there is not a defence against mindless brutality. Some people had no choice but to react with brutality. There was also a warning about reactionary laws rushed in without being thought through.
Ken Loach's timing is impeccable. The film was informative and realistic, sad and humorous, evocative and earthy. The music was integral to the ethnicity and culture of the backdrop, but understated rather than overblown. A less flamboyant film than "Michael Collins", it neatly compliments that film and dovetails by providing an essential précis to the background of a person from Collins' upbringing, influences and environment in West Cork, without overtly dominating the film.