Fails miserably and doesn't even fit into the horror/mystery category at all

Rating: 4/10 (9 September 2004)

This "horror/mystery" movie has two main problems: it has not a single remotely scary moment, and it isn't too mysterious after half of the film. The myriads of plot holes and inconsistencies don't make it better. I think I won't spoil anything if I say that there's an oh-so-surprising twist at the end, but this can't save the movie, it actually makes it worse: for one you can see it coming quite early and then it's simply stupid.
The cast features some great names and some of the characters have the potential to be interesting, but ultimately all are bland and forgettable. I acknowledge trying to make a horror/mystery flick without the exhausted alien/monster clichés, unfortunately it fails miserably and doesn't even fit into that category at all.