Not bad, Not great

Rating: 5/10 (31 January 2005)

This movie was interesting....you come in thinking its a horror/thriller, but in reality its more a mystery/character study. The reason I gave it a 5, is because of the plot holes. That, and it was a tad boring....there were some sections that just seemed to drag on....but the best part of this movie is the atmosphere that is provided by the pennsilvania backdrop. the fog, grass, woods etc. made it very relaxing....acting was great too. The young girl, who plays a blind woman is superb. Joquin Pheonix is good as well. There were all stage actors, and it shows. This movie could be a play...a lot of dialogue, but worth seeing if you like different movies. There are some surpises, but unfortunately for me , the plot holes that lead to the surprise annoyed me enough to submit a 5. enjoy!