decent enough

Rating: 6/10 (22 November 2009)

i haven't read any of the books, so this is based just on the film.
And it has more good aspects than bad ones. it has been beautifully shot and has occasional visually epic cinematic moments. the acting is solid, even if some of the characters lack a little dimension, with Charlie Swan (Billy Burke), although not in it much, being the most buy-able character. in a world of fantasy, character depth is sorely needed to make any of it believable. but if u accept the world its set in and are willing to go along for the ride, you shouldn't feel too perturbed, you'll get to see some stunning CGI that you wont see anywhere else, u might say "transformative". the narrative is a little patchy and jumpy at points but easy enough to follow, and makes enough sense to keep the interest. overall I'm satisfied to have seen it but i wont be rushing out to see it again.