a eclipse better than sun?!

Rating: Null/10 (6 March 2011)

let me at first make some categories and ranked them so that my approach to this movie will be crystal clear: ACTING: good, not perfect. the main 3 actors (Pattinson, Stewart, and Lautner) are still immature and young, so there should not be high expectations. although, Lautner's voice is as nice as it should be. in the book, it is described as "husky" and it is. I wonder if it's one of the reasons why he has been chosen for the role! Charlie is totally believable and much like the book. thank you Billy Burke! MUSIC: perfect, it was chosen very carefully and correctly. i like the music in the mock battle, the music in the Cullen's house when Bella ans Edward are alone in his room, and the music in the Edward and Victoria's fight. they are really awesome. SCREENPLAY: good enough. i know it's too hard to write a screenplay based on novel. because when you want to visualize a text, you have to omit thing which can't come to pictures such as thoughts and feelings that have a very important role in books. at last i think this movie is better than previous one (new moon) and as lovely as the first one (twilight). although i still strongly believe the books are sth else!