I was eager for the final battle, because everything else was so so. But then, the final battle was not as expected.

Rating: 5/10 (20 May 2020)

The music, score, tone, opening and end credit sequences, and casting are perfect for the movie.
The visual effects are okay, but Bella's first hunt scene does not look smooth. The action scenes are not as expected, the Volturi holds back. Most of the conflicts are unnecessary and underdeveloped, because they are only caused by misunderstanding or lack of self-control. The vampires gathering and Volturi's visit are just for the sake of the movie, because it could easily be solved through a fair trial or discussion. The final resolution was weak, because the Volturi just leaves, although they bring huge army. Since the final battle is only Alice's alternate vision, it undercuts the risk that the movie offers. The imprint is interesting but is not sufficient to solve the conflicts. The emotion of almost all characters in the movie is very unstable.
Debatable holes:
1) Why did the Volturi have to wait for few days to come to the Cullens?
2) Baby Renesmee did not have vampire features, like eyes, fangs, skin and body temperature, or constant physical need for blood.
3) How could Bella hold herself when Charlie came to the Cullen's? Baby Renesmee also did nothing when she was on Jacob's arms or near humans.
4) For convenience, the Cullens easily have the wealth and easy access to airplane ticket and housing furniture.
5) If the Volturi was some kind of government for the vampires, why did they not have system for crime reporting, fair trial, discussion, proof gathering and validation, and trustworthy members? The members only acted based on their instinct and emotion.
6) How could Jacob know that the 'uninvited' vampires were uninvited? What about the Amazonian ones?
7) Bella ridiculously easily control her desire for human blood.
8) Edward could have easily read Alice's mind.
9) How could the vampires control themselves when Jacob was in the house? How could the 'food' be sustainable and enough for all?
10) How did all vampires know about Carlisle's intention to gather witnesses? Did he called them? Why did they need to travel, then?
11) How could Bella have the defensive power when she was in human form? Could humans have powers as well? How could the power be so random and extensively powerful, like controlling elements?
12) Why was Bella so special that her power was always active even when no one realized it and she did not know about it?
13) Alice's vision could change, but it never happened. It was too convenient for the Cullens.
14) How far could Alice see the future? What were the constraints? Did she always have to watch the one she was trying to sense? How many people could she sense at the same time? Did they have to be in certain range?
15) When Carlisle's vampire friends and family went back, the Volturi could just attack the Cullens easily.
16) What did the Volturi want exactly? What were their job and responsibilities as 'Volturi'?
17) In the battle, the Volturi could defeat the Cullens and friends very easily. Jane's pain ability could be very effective.
18) Sometimes, a vampire could easily break another vampire's head/limbs easily, but sometimes, it is not the case.
19) Why was immortal child so dangerous? Why could the vampires not able to restraint/train it? What made a regular vampire child and an immortal child different?
20) Why would Irina not tell her assumption about immortal child to her family first? Why did she not ask for explanation first?
21) Why did anyone think that Renesmee could pose a threat?
22) Why did Alice and Jasper have to go secretly?