9/10 Flawed still genius

Rating: 9/10 (22 January 2002)

The Thin Red Line is a war movie that would rather look at the effects of war in a philosophical sense and in an environmental sense. The film is far from perfect, but there is just so much greatness to the film, it's impossible to ignore. Wonderful performances, gorgeous film, and thought provoking. A good war film that can hold its own with many movies.
Many believe the film is superior to Saving Private Ryan. I myself have always like Ryan better, but I find Three Kings and Black Hawk Down to both be superior.