Why? No Answer!

Rating: 10/10 (14 March 1999)

What makes philosophy worth thinking about?
1. You get questions instead of answers 2. These questions haven´t a correct answer
a)Who I am? b)Where do I go? c)What is it we´re living for?
TRL gives answers to this
a)A dirty piece of meat, called soldier ( or human being) b)Up this hill as the commander told c)death
A last question rises
Why?
And as "Ryan" tells us: For your country, for the good side... TRL leaves us alone with this question. Homer (Nolte quotes him) and buddhism can´t bring us an answer and so the movie doesn´t because Malick knows there is no answer.
Negative critics won´t make me feel different about this movie That´s my opinion, and everybody should have one, at least.
But reading more than fifty times the summary "worst film ever" shows the indoctrination of Hollywood-Lullaby-Soaps. SPR shows blood and pure instinct, mixed with the typically tough guy-actors and dumb phrases. TRL is what I would like to see after SPR as introduction.
10 points out of 10 for this fragment that made me wonder about nature, being a human, life and what this all means.