average war film

Rating: 7/10 (18 January 1999)

The Thin Red Line, Terrance Malick's first film in over 20 years, is not nearly as good as Saving Private Ryan. The story of The Thin Red Line is confusing. Malick is overly symbolic. Some shots, like that of a bird dying, are vivid, but others are pointless. Too many symbols defeats the purpose of symbolism. The narration is also confusing, as sometimes it is hard to tell who is talking. Most performances are great. Sean Penn is excellent. I wish the story revolved around him more. He offers an honest performance and the story behind his character is the most interesting of the many stories. Nick Nolte has his moments, but he is for the most part overly melodramatic. John Cusack and Woody Harrelson are great in their roles, as are many of the lesser name actors who have good sized parts, such as Private Witt. The film drags along, unlike Private Ryan, this film felt longer than it was. The symbolism surrounding the tribe in the beginning is too vague. The battles scenes are well done though and I can appreciate the shots of Malick. He would be well advised to become a director for hire. He is a fine director, but his writing leaves a lot to be desired. Give us more of Sean Penn.