More Original Than Saving Private Ryan

Rating: Null/10 (21 January 1999)

Terrence Malick is one of the most original directors out there. True, this is only his 3rd film. But it really showcases his love for the unconventional narrative and inner monologues that work so well. In many ways, it's very Robert Altmanesque in the way he goes from character to character. Unlike Saving Private Ryan, Thin Red Line doesn't settle in cliche plot development and over-sentimentality. The characters and acting are far better. Sean Penn is still one of the finest actors of all time, and his subtleness is a welcome change of pace from the insanity he displayed in She's So Lovely. Nolte is brilliant as well. I think The Thin Red Line brings something new to the now tiresome war genre. It doesn't cop out from the darkness and brutality. Saving Private Ryan, although a very good film as well, is just Spielberg doing Spielberg with the exception of the battle scenes. In The Thin Red Line, Malick doesn't candy coat or present any flaws in this remarkable picture that, despite its slow pace, must be seen!