A Masterfully Crafted Emotional Roller Coaster Ride

Rating: 10/10 (13 August 2002)

I will not rehash the plot outline as many other reviewers have done a fine job of presenting it. Note, however, that this is not an action/adventure film. It is not fast-paced. It is grueling and harsh in part. But it evolves into a moving story of the triumph of indomitable human spirit over crushing adversity.
"The Shawshank Redemption" packs an intense and unforgettable emotional wallop. Thanks to a perfect blend of cinematography, acting, soundtrack, and plot development, the film takes the viewer on an unforgettable emotional roller coaster ride. It masterfully elicits powerful emotions running the gamut from the lowest lows to the highest highs.
I read a great number of other IMDb members' excellent comments on this film. I think it is safe to say that those of us who rate "Shawshank" among our favorite movies share one view in common --we truly FELT the impact of this film.
Some who disliked the film have argued that certain aspects of the plot are unrealistic. I must note that I thoroughly enjoyed the plot itself. Nonetheless, is every element of the story realistic? It really doesn't matter.
This is not a purely plot-driven vehicle. This is far more than a "life in prison" film. The prison serves as the framework in an ongoing struggle between hope and hopelessness under the most adverse circumstances. The beauty of "Shawshank" is the way it excels in evoking a great range of human emotions while presenting a fulfilling and moving tale of resilient human spirit.
Whether viewed as "true to life" or a parable, "Shawshank" succeeds in making us really care about the main characters. It is unsurpassed in making the viewer feel the full emotional impact of events as they unfold. It excels in making us feel fine gradations of despair and hope, cruelty and kindness, hatred and friendship, sadness and joy.
Along with the excellence of the film as a whole, I consider a certain scene among the most intense, fulfilling and memorable moments I have experienced in cinema. (I won't discuss it for the benefit of those who have not yet seen the film.)
"The Shawshank Redemption" is a true masterpiece of film making. It is unsurpassed in evoking a full range of intense human emotions as it proceeds to an unforgettable conclusion. It fully deserves its place as one of the all-time greats in film history.