So-so prelude to "The Producers" musical

Rating: Null/10 (8 July 2002)

I'm not a huge fan of Mel Brooks movies, I admit. They have good lines, but as coherent movies, they usually come up short. Such is the case of "The Producers". Although it may be a "cult" classic, it never became a REAL classic because it just doesn't work in this format.
BUT as a Broadway musical (THE PRODUCERS, that is, not SPRINGTIME FOR HITLER) it is a real gem. Brooks' talent comes through full force, but he gave enough authority to other people involved to cut out his often silly, un-funny sophomoric humor, probably since this was his first play. Watching the movie now simply reminds one of all the great musical numbers in the broadway show. In the genre of great old musical comedies, it is set in the 1950s and works much better that way.
The movie however, taking place in the "present", i.e. 1968, the classic musical was already going out of fashion, and it is no surprise that Max was no longer successful. The contemporary sixties clothing, sets, and "L.S.D." are out of place as they do not conjure up images of classic broadway musicals and the atmosphere that went along with them.

If you like the movie, you'll love the musical. This movie was BEGGING to be made into one, and I'm glad it finally happened. I just hope Mel is able to bring it to the big screen one day, although it probably won't be until the touring company finishes, and that may not be for years and years. In the meantime, get your tickets (a year in advance) and make your plans to go to NYC or London, or wherever it's playing when you read this (even your community theatre someday?).
Don't miss the late great Chris "Mr. Belvedere" Hewitt as Roger DeBris.