Wonderful Film!!!

Rating: 10/10 (1 May 2005)

Once again, I apparently stand alone. This is one of my all-time favorite movies, and I'm guessing that's because I'm no "history buff." Let's, for a moment, look at this just as it is: a movie. It isn't a documentary meant for educational value, it's not there to be another Braveheart, and it's surely not there for flag-waving. It's a story about family and loss, rebuilding and fighting...all supported by great acting and wonderful music. No matter what, any "music buff" cannot deny that...and yes, I'm claiming to be one.
I'll never understand why people who watch historical films or period movies always expect and demand absolutely correct material be embedded in the main story. It's a story inspired by a war. If you look at it like it's meant to be looked at...a MOVIE...and not created to appease a fetish for historical correctness, then you may walk away with more appreciation for it.
*Spoilers after this point* Mel Gibson really pulled out a great performance, especially during Gabriel's death. There is something haunting and stirring about his reaction...almost too real for comfort. Jason Isaacs was brilliantly cast for Col. Tavington and performed it with absolute vileness. Even Heath Ledger did a good job with his role. The music is some of my favorite from John Williams...you can't go wrong with him...and the cinematography was beautiful.
Overall, it's not even wise to watch a Hollywood film expecting things to be just as you've read in History books. It's like historical fiction novels...it's a story, and an excellent one at that. A personal favorite. :)