Masterfully written&directed,brilliant cast and true English Redcoats

Rating: 10/10 (25 September 2004)

Not so many movies tackle this part of the American history/world history.
The script and plot are far more subtle than some would have it.For instance, look at and listen closely to the convention held in Charleston at the beginning of the picture. It is magnificent drama and magnificently rhetorical indeed (a treat!!) . Mel Gibson is overwhelmingly brilliant. "Would you tell me please, Mr. Howard,Why should I trade one tyrant 3000 miles away for 3000 tyrants one mile away?" (Mel Gibson's "why"is still echoing..). I find no weakness in the plot, of course some are ill at ease with good sentiments and patriotism, but the film is much more than that. The encounter with Cornwallis (Tom Wilkinson is ever so impressive)is superb. The stark contrast between the English side and the American one may seem a caricature, but I am convinced it does reflect the profound differences that could be found at that time. As for the cast, the fact that all the red coats are played by English actors enhances the quality of the whole undertaking. The French actor Tcheky Karyo also adds to the compelling dimension of the film. Every part is brilliantly acted and we must not underestimate the quality of the performance of Heath Ledger or that of the colonel of the British cavalry. Watching this film only once is a crime. It's a true masterpiece
TK