Great movie

Rating: Null/10 (9 January 2003)

Please excuse the advanced critique that IMDB has posted with this movie. I have to say, it was obviously generated by someone schooled in the film industry who has very hardened opinions on what constitutes good filmmaking. Unless you are looking to view this film with a critical eye or rip it apart for your script writing class, you will hardly notice half the things mentioned in the previous critique.
This movie was astounding in its ability to portray a true fantasy story in a dramatic, serious fashion. American filmmakers seem to have a block when it comes to science fiction and fantasy and seem to want to "silly it up" for the kids. This movie does not have any of this. It is given all the serious attention this type of story deserves. I am *very* pleased with this. I feel the fantasy character of Gimli was expounded upon as a dwarf in the way that Legolas was as an elf in the first movie. We got to see dwarves as they should be portrayed, with laughing good cheer, belching good appetites, and an at times comical battle lust.
This movie is just a heavenly delight for a true fantasy lover. Even if you've never read Tolkien, just newer fantasy novels, you'll recognize all your characters in these people.
My one critique would be in casting of the Lorien elves which come to assist at the battle of Rohan. The leader was chubby enough to be a dwarf, practically. :) But what is suspension of disbelief for, anyway...?