Another 10, not perfect, but in the top 1% of all-time.

Rating: 10/10 (19 December 2002)

This film was certainly a 10 when evaluated as a separate work. (and by 10 I mean that it was in the top 10% of all movies, probably in the top 1%) For those expecting devotion to Tolkien, don't. However, the diversions from the storyline were interesting and well done.
SMEAGOL was terrific! He was funny, pitiful and somewhat scary. He truly ran the gamut. If he is not nominated for an oscar the Academy will lose credibility. **SPOILER** The scene where he talks to himself is one of the best on film.
The performances of the other cast members were very well done. Believability in a fantasy film is often difficult to pull off as other films of the genre have demonstrated. This is why I think the actors in this film are so talented. Without exception I sat there watching and I believed they were who thy portrayed.
For Tolkien fans the film captured the mood and message of his trilogy, if not the encompasing world of Middle-Earth. Certainly I would have enjoyed seeing more of the Ents, Gollum and the emotional struggles Sam and Frodo went thorough with Farimir. I can understand these scenes may not be as entertaining on film.
Well, thanks again Peter J. I appreciate your attention to detail and the seeming effortlessness you displayed in delivering one of the greatest literary works of the last century. Very smooth.