Great

Rating: 10/10 (22 April 2006)

It is freaking hard to make a movie out of a book,. The main problem is that the book inspires as many visions of the story as there are readers reading it. Now if one guy (in this case three) writes a script it will by all means not satisfy everybody. It can't. Remember when you read the books I mean it was your story it was your vision it was your world. Now there's someone stepping in here and telling you it's different from what you thought it was. Well of course it's not gonna work. I think Peter Jackson has created a film that reflects a book as good as possible, especially an epic story like TLOTR, which at one point can be looked at as a mythology of England. So do the Nibelungenlied or homer's Odyssey with an equal amount of success. I don't think so! It is art and not everybody is an artist. Sorry but Peter Jackson is the one and only who ever brought justification to a book.