Most of it is wonderful- so what is with the bad CGI???

Rating: 7/10 (21 December 2003)

Good points: -The battle scenes are amazing -Frodo and Sam! Like others said, I can not picture anyone else playing them. S.Astin and E.Wood did such a great job in the 3 movies. -The scenery-beautiful. -Shelob looks real!
Bad points: -Legolas jumping on the mammoth-looks SO fake. Why stick things like this in when other scenes are so amazing??? -The army of the dead moves way too fast-fake, fake, fake... -Bad makeup on some characters (Bilbo at the end.) -Weird cuts and fades at some points. -P. Jackson must be in love with Liv Tyler, he focuses on her face for LONG amounts of time. Why spend so long on these scenes like this and cut out great scenes from the books? -Characters saying there's in the wrong context. As in "there's armys on their way towards us right now..." There IS armys?? This sounds so stupid and people would never speak this way back then. It just ruins the moment and makes you remember oh yeah, these are modern day people that speak wrong. Caught it several times-if I can, why can't the writers/director fix this?!