Good but overrated

Rating: 7/10 (20 July 2006)

This movie was good if not very good but in my mind is vastly overrated. why is this number 4 in the chart? LOTR had epic fight scenes a strong plot a satisfying ending (that went on far to long but still left lots of questions unanswered) But overall seems like I'd seen it all in the first and second movie. It was like it was all done before. One of the many last scenes contained the part where aragon bowed to the hobbits but really they quite frankly the hobbits did a bad job carrying the ring and any of the other characters would have done a better job. The Gollom story was entertaining but played too small a part in the movie they should have focused on the hobbits and personally I think should have cut all the parts with the two twin hobbits. Also the part with the spider was dull. why did they not kill the spider, spill it's guts.
Don't get me wrong this was a good movie but is overrated to what it actually achieved.