POSSIBLE SPOILERS - It gets 9 but it's not as faithful to the book as it could've been

Rating: 6/10 (18 December 2003)

This is truly a fantastic film but, if like me, you're a fan of the book then you will be slightly disappointed/insulted/offended. It pains me a great deal to say this as I was all set for a 10/10 and the most fantastic review ever but I just can't do that. And that's possibly why I'm still so disappointed.
However, go and see it - it's a wondrous film with the most incredible acting. The special effects are truly awe-inspiring and the Battle of Pelennor Fields is amazing - you feel as if you're there.
Yes the ending could be described as long and drawn-out. But, compared to the book, it's a trifle short - and utterly different.
Ok, I'll give it a 10 as a film but I'll always be slightly disappointed.