Capital Goof - an open appeal  Dear Peter (and NLC) . . ."

Rating: 9/10 (14 October 2007)

... thank you for your fine work on Lord...". You've done it right and well and about time. Many people had looked forward to what you finally accomplished and you didn't disappoint us.
With basically one capital exception!
It is obligatory that you do The Hobbit" and show how terrific dwarvens really are! An Elf may be one hell of a long-distance-fighter, an astonishing acrobat and a superior in strategic warfair. But NEVER EVER will an Elf compete against a Dwarf in close-combat and long-range-drinking! An Elf hits the bar-room floor after one cream-liquor, a dwarf parties on for nights. That goof between Gimli and Legolas at the end of ROTK" was unacceptable particularly after Legolas has already been shown as the generally superior fighter to Gimli almost all through the trilogy! Which kinda made me mad as well...
I as much as many other Dwarven-fans- insist you to do The Hobbit" and put things right about our favourite fellows (or whoever may do it in the end).
As soon as you did, I'll have you your tenth star here. Thank you, don't mind.
ZWERGE  DAS EINZIG WAHRE!