My thoughts...

Rating: 10/10 (17 December 2003)

In my opinion this is the best movie of the series. Alot was changed, but I think the changes made this a better movie. I'm not a total freak and I dont even expect this to be EXACTLY as the book. some things just wouldn't work in a movie. also, a lot was deleted, but as I hope and believe, extended edition will make this movie ALOT better.. easily the best movie of all time, which it already is.
acting was good overall, but Theoden (Bernard Hill), Eomer (Karl Urban) and Sam (Sean Astin) really convinced me. EXCELLENT acting from these three guys!
I really hope Peter Jackson wins the 'best director' oscar. the directing has been so magnificent in all three movie that it's about the time to take the trophy! the scene where pippin is singing and Faramir is riding to war is already an oscar worth performance!