Maybe not the best review in the world but ... judge for yourself!

Rating: Null/10 (31 October 2004)

I finally felt moved enough to comment on IMDb. I watch a lot of films and usually come here to get an idea what to expect beforehand. If I had paid any attention to half of the user comments for LOTR: ROTK I'd have probably given it a miss. The fact is that it is a stunning film worthy of all the plaudits, and I urge anyone to watch it and judge for their self.
There seem to be a lot of comments on here written by cynical people who need a film to be smugly clever to appreciate it's worth. There also seem to be people who need to belittle anything related to the 'fantasy' genre to drive their cynicism home. Pretty sad.
Go watch! :)