Is it which one?

Rating: Null/10 (14 December 2004)

That refers to the fact of the extended edition(in my opinion) being so much better. What i hated in the third movie was, sad to say, that it felt too much cut. There were clear gaps in the story and 48 minutes of new material make the story now complete, thus rising my original 4 stars to full 5.
So, if I now review the extended version. Well to begin with the feeling's GREAT! the original Lord of the Rings is on screen again. Right starting from the appearing of Saruman to the Ending of the film. What a bad decision to cut that out from the original. In the Extended version you have a hole nother adventure. The true and final ending of the excellent trilogy of movies. The AMAZING battle scenes as well as the intense character relations come to a full circle. Yeah, you might say that there are "too many" endings but the movie is no lesser. It kinda has to be that way.
As in an article I read: Of course Tolkien's books are the most powerful Middle-Earth, but would anyone even deared to imagine the book like Peter Jackson.
This movie trilogy should live forever, and it most likely will... This is great movie making, but most of all it is Middle-Earth ON screen...