I couldn't believe it.

Rating: 10/10 (19 October 2005)

I could not believe what I had seen when I walked out of the theater about 2 years ago. This is probably the greatest movie I've ever seen. About a year ago I saw the extended version, and I can only say that the 50 minutes only add to the experience. But, as great as this movie is, it has its share of flaws. Gandalf speaking to pippin about a "far green country". The point of that was....? Acting is not terrible, not as bad as some people say. Special effects are amazing. Mt. Doom, the eye of Sauron and Shelob looked great. The battle at the Black Gate was good, but pales compared to the battle of Pelennor Fields. This is EASILY the best of the 3 rings. In my opinion, it is not overrated at all. Is it worth renting? No. This masterpiece is worth owning, especially the extended edition.