The Return of the Epic

Rating: 10/10 (20 December 2003)

The critique that Saruman was noticeably absent is accurate. The critique that the ending went on a bit too long is accurate. The critique that the score was unoriginal is accurate (however it does provide continuity with the previous movies-as it should).
HOWEVER - those critiques are in the deep shadows of this brilliant final film. Overwhelming is perhaps the best adjective for this.

Jackson demonstrates not only great direction, but incredible vision, and huge cajones. It will be a long time (maybe never) before anyone tries anything as ambitious as this and not only pulls it off but does so spectacularly. If they ever run all three movies together, I'll buy a seat cushion and be first in line.