3rd part is the worst part (of the movies)

Rating: 3/10 (9 September 2005)

I love the books of Tolkien, and I think it's hard for every director to use such a draft for a movie which has to satisfy millions of expectant viewers. But sorry, I don't see the brilliance and own style of Peter Jackson, which in my opinion has to be there for rating this movie so good.
An important point is the missing "atmosphere" in the film. In the most threatening situations, the characters are still able to joke around and so destroy the atmosphere (I also don't want to see Michael Myers talking in Halloween, or make some jokes about his victims - that would destroy the atmosphere). Well, it's true, the books have also such scenes, but I think thats deliberately exaggerated to create this atmosphere like it's in f. ex. Beowulf. Thats not important and not meaningful for the movie...
OK, because I think every mediocre director can make a worth-seeing movie out of such great books, I can give the books 10 but the movie only 3 points. And in fact, the 3rd movie is really good in this digital stuff, but this incredible dialogues -thats really like Hollywood! Thats for the 3rd part, in my opinion the first part is the best one....
bye fans