Great movie from the point of view of a tolkien fan

Rating: 9/10 (12 June 2005)

This movie really fills the expectations of that many Tolkien fans that have been waiting for it, all the characters perform greatly and are like just extracted from the books, the plot hangs the viewer easily, so do the books, and the scenarios are simply GREAT.
I didn't have much faith in that movies because I found very difficult for them to make me feel the epic of the books, that feelings of friendship, honor and adventure but they have succeed and I can't get disappointed, thnx mr. Jackson! In the other side, I don't give a 10/10 because I think some commercial aspects have been included on the movie, and man, sure it doesn't need them. I'm talking about the protagonist given to Arwen, u don't need to always center a movie in a love story! I'm simply fed up of that and was one of the point I really enjoyed from the books, and I got disappointed with some stupid scenes like the stairs falling in moria with the characters jumping to the other side or the stupid shield ride in the second movie.
For me It's a pity to find that stupid mistakes in such a great films, but I congratulate Peter Jackson for these great movies so must do all the fans of the Tolkien trilogy.