A faithful, excellent adaptation

Rating: 10/10 (19 December 2001)

Keep in mind as I write that I grew up with the Lord of the Rings. So I suppose I am another one of these "fan boys" that loved it to death simply because it's any nerd's wet dream to see the books come to life.
However, the books were flawed greatly. Basis of all modern fantasy or not, Tolkien rambles, and is not the most intriguing writer of his generation, contrary to what many say.
That said, Peter Jackson's Fellowship of the Ring is a brilliant movie. Gone are long, dragging scenes from the novel, like the one in Mirkwood. Even without such excess baggage, the film still runs 3 hours, which means that enough of the novel is retained to satisfy all but the most rabid fans.
But let me skip the know-it-all perspective and get down to what you want to know. The fight scenes are wonderfully choreographed, the acting ranges from acceptable to great, the special effects are good, the film's pacing is excellent considering its length, and yes, every important scene in the book is preserved and represented well. Certain things are explained numerous times so as to get the casual fans to understand; others are not explained enough, but overall I had no problem with how much history was divulged. Keep in mind that I read the books. I cannot tell you if a virgin-Tolkeinite would understand this film fully.
I suppose the most impressive thing about Jackson's Fellowship of the Ring is the pervading feeling of desperation and abject terror. Most movies are content to tell you that the characters are scared of something. The Fellowship of the Ring draws you in and frightens you too. There were scenes when my muscles were clenched throughout, hoping desperately that my heroes would escape, despite technically already knowing what happens. The orcs and other evil forces are mostly convincing. The power of the ring, shown in various scenes throughout the movie, is downright terrifying. Those with children be warned: this movie is not to be confused with Harry Potter. The epic, seemingly hopeless battle between good and evil is likely to much for many small children to handle.
Overall, The Fellowship of the Ring is a very faithful adaptation of the novel. After the movie was over I was already giddy with anticipation of the next installment. You'd better believe that before that happens, I will see The Fellowship of the Ring again, and perhaps read through the books a third time if I have a chance. A thrilling epic, I rate this a 9/10.