My voting criteria

Rating: 10/10 (20 December 2001)

My three criteria for voting were:
do I want to see the film again? will I buy the DVD when it is released? does it make me want to read the book?
Answers in order:
Yes, Yes and No (but it did make me want to re-read the book) and I now want to read the Silmarillion.
My only negative comment "the book is better!"