Faithful. Epic. Wonderful

Rating: 9/10 (21 December 2001)

There's too much to say about what is so wonderful about this film. I suppose initially you have to say that the effort that went into this project is amazing. From sets to effects and especially to acting this film has it all. Action, love, friendship, special effects, great characters and a feeling of a story of epic proportions. Ian McKellen is a wonder, a disciple of his craft but all in all the performances were striking. The locations, the action, the themes of friendship, sacrifice and the greater good all there.
Is it a perfect film? Well no. So there's a few changes from the book but to be honest most of them are required. But despite the few niggling things like Galadriel being either half asleep or over the top and the absence of any real feeling of how much time has passed, it's a beautiful labour of love.
It's long and the first hour IS slow so don't expect the immediate effect of a blockbuster straight off. When it gets going though, watch out, things really are amazing. From the Mines of Moria to the final heart breaking scenes we are treated to the first classic of the 21st century.