The first classic film version of a classic

Rating: 10/10 (9 August 2002)

A classic can be defined as a work of art or literature that is viewed or read long after it was created. Different people have different ideas on what "long" means; some say 50 years, some say 100 years, and so on. However many years "long" means, Tolkien's writings about Middle-earth, particularly The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and The Silmarillion are well on their way to becoming classics, if they are not already so.
Others have made film adaptations of The Hobbit and LOTR. Others will do so again. Perhaps somebody will make a movie or series of movies based on The Silmarillion. Some of these will stand the test of time and become classics, others will not. Of all the movies that do become classics, the three made by Peter Jackson based on LOTR are the first, in my opinion. I've only seen the first, like everybody else, but I believe that seeing all three in a single session would be like seeing a nine-hour movie with two intermissions.
It's true that the movie I've seen does not conform 100% to the text; no movie does, nor can it do so. But it's about as faithful to the text as is humanly possible. It's obvious that PJ, the cast, and the crew really cared about the story. They wanted to do the job and do it right. Did they succeed? The results speak for themselves.
Here we have three movies that you either love or hate, based on a book that you either love or hate. The intention is that, having seen the movies, those who hate the book will learn to tolerate it, and later love it, and those who love the book will love it more. I think it succeeds in its intention. Read the book, see the movies, and make up your own mind.