"No one knows its here, do they? Do they, Gandalf?"

Rating: 7/10 (30 July 2003)

Peter Jackson has an epic vision, there's no denying it. Everything we see is on a grand scale and is hurried in and out in the same pace. Jackson doesn't want to stop and become a character study or evolve the characters; he wants to draw us into this fantasy Middle Earth he is so proud of. And since he concentrates on beauty; that's all he achieves.
The story-telling is extremely cliche. Especially for a fantasy film. Something is threatening the world and everyone must use their courage to fight the forces of evil. I'm not attacking the film, really, but more the original novel and script. The novels are good fantasy, yes -- but do we really need the same story over and over? I don't think so.
The acting is typical fantasy fare; self-important and even self indulgent for most of it's running time ... the actors are the same. No one gives a stand out performance. The actors walk around and meet with other actors, and you can practically see the script when they talk.
The cinematography and set designs are lush, but utterly pointless if nothing gives interest in the surroundings. It looks good, yes. It's a grand scale and it's a grand story and a vast achievement across the board. They're succeeded in bringing the Lord of the Rings to life. Ok, now what?
The score is good but expected and really doesn't get anxious, or rushed. But, it's no risk style bores me, because we've heard it somewhere before -- typical fantasy fare. throughout it's 3 hour running time. I was taken aback by the harmony of sound and music. This is what made me look past it's flaws and now they're too strong to ignore. The whole movie I feel like I'm waiting on something big to happen, like everything is being built up and readying me for something amazing and yet it falls ultimately flat.
Not quite the masterpiece it's made out to be but it's still a good film. But, I hesitate to give it a perfect score for obvious flaws in its screen-writing and acting.
C+: If you're a fan of the genre indulge yourself in this visual landmark. If you're looking for strong story-telling and serious acting -- put your money elsewhere.