A masterful representation of J.R.R. Tolkien's literary classic.

Rating: 10/10 (24 December 2001)

Let me first say that I loved the movie. Peter Jackson did a wonderful job in bringing this epic story, loved by millions, from print to big screen. Yes, there was some differences from the novel to the screen, but there had to be some omissions. No studio would have backed this movie with longer than a 3 hour run time and only the die-hard fans would have sat through it. Even at its 2 hour and 58 minutes, it feels a little long. I can't imagine what I would have cut out of this to make it any shorter. I also wouldn't have dared to add anything else. The $75 million dollar five day weekend opening was outstanding. I'm shocked it could pull that amount with the fewer times it could be shown due to its length. I've seen the movie twice now. I saw it on opening day in a packed theater and everyone loved it. I finished my second viewing earlier this evening and tried to catch some of the more subtle things intended for those who had read the books. For example, the cloaks that all of the fellowship are wearing when they leave Lothlorien.
What I liked ... All of the cast (yes, even Liv Tyler) was perfect. I can't imagine one person I would have changed. I have to admit that Hugo Weaving as Elrond still reminded me of Agent Smith from the Matrix. Gandalf was wonderful. I'd use his real name, but I think that is his real name now. Frodo and Aragorn were nicely played. The actor playing Legolas was given some of the greatest action moments.
What I disliked ... I'm hard pressed to find much. I would have liked the characters of Boromir and Gimli more developed. For instance, I think Gimli's transformation before and after visiting Lothlorien would have been great to see on screen. Jackson tried to explain Boromir's whole character in his last scene and it just isn't enough. The only other thing I might have done differently is the ending. I can tell you that there was a collective 'aaarrggghhh' from the whole theater both times I saw this movie. It really feels like you left the theater seeing one third of a movie, which is ok if you've read the books and understand that this was a natural stopping point. But if you are someone new to the Rings trilogy, it feels like they pulled the rug out from under you. Perhaps this was what Peter Jackson was going for... "always leave them wanting more." :) My favorite movie moment ... When Gandalf arrives in the Shire the first time. It is just magic! No pun intended. His playfulness with the children is priceless. I gave this movie a 10. Even though it is only a partial telling of a much larger story, it truly is near perfect. It's only shortcomings are brought about by time constraints. Thank you Peter Jackson!