The Best Film of All Time, so far.

Rating: 10/10 (15 August 2002)

Its interesting that approximately two-thirds of those who have viewed this film give it a 10 out of 10, and yet you read reviews that infer this was a terrible movie. I guess there is no accounting for taste, but if 60% of the voting public thinks this movie is a "10" then I think you are safe in spending the time and money to view it.
Having just watched The Godfather a few months ago after discovering this website, it is difficult to understand why it is rated above LOTR:FOTR. FOTR is more exciting, with more beautiful scenery, equal direction, equally convincing acting, better camera angles, less offensive language, funnier comedy, and much better special effects. The only areas where The Godfather could be argued superior is specifically the realism and drama of the film. Yet isn't a films value based on its ability to take you from reality, captivate your senses for a few short hours and communicate with your soul through your emotions.
Fellowship of The Rings is a rollercoaster of humor, joy, fear, disgust, beauty, responsibility, duty and love. I have read many reviews and those critical of the film rarely can point to specific failings, because the scenes are masterfully done.
The opening scene in the Shire is warm and cozy with an air of mystery and a dollop of humor. Even the fireworks display is a spectacular display of eyecandy.
Each scene that follows moves the story along and simultaneously is enjoyable in and of itself.
A movie can't be too long if you enjoy every minute. I also was sad at the end, like others have commented, because I wanted to continue to admire Peter Jackson's masterpiece. One of, if not the Best Films of All time, till Christmas 2002. (I hope)