ignore bad reviews

Rating: 10/10 (13 February 2002)

Have you noticed that all the people who gave FOTR bad reviews didn't know anything about it, (and obviously have no imagination)? I have read the book, and admit the film isn't perfect (too many cliched scenes), but it IS middle-earth, and they ARE the characters from the book, and it IS a brilliant film. I wont ramble on too much, but my best friend loved it, and he hadn't read any Tolkien in his life. (p.s. - i recently saw 'Walkabout', which leaves the viewer with many questions - if the critics called it genius in Walkabout, what's wrong with it in FOTR?!!!)