Very good, yet...

Rating: 8/10 (6 July 2002)

...they could have made it a bit more dark and dirty...everything felt too fresh...Bag End was like it had just been made..."let's throw some things around so it looks as if somebody has lived here for a looooong time...not! same goes for Moria, but still I'm looking forward to the next film...this trilogy will become a must see...just like Tolkien's books have been...=) // sf