Magic

Rating: Null/10 (6 January 2002)

*spoilers* This has to be one of the best films I have seen for a long time. It stays so faithful to the book and all of the characters are just how I pictured them. Its no good people saying that it was a waste of time and that it was boring,all of the scenes were in the book. And whats with all the complaining about the traveling? its a journey!
They cut out Tom Bombadil (and with good cause)because if they hadn't then the whole film would have been turned into a musical and his shoes were filled in with Liv Tyler,who's character appears in the third book (The Return of The King) anyway. I think it was a work of art and I can understand that people who have not read the book might find 3 hours of talking and walking and a little fighting quite overwhelming. Those who want a treat go to see it.