They did it, I'll be dammed if they didn't actually do it

Rating: Null/10 (1 February 2002)

Filled all my expectations, including leaving out tom bombadil, which I thought was somewhat irrelevant unless you had read the Silmarillion and the guide to middle earth.
Some things out of sequence from the book, but for very valid reasons.
Anyone whinning about it, let's see you do better!