Great or good ?

Rating: 7/10 (28 April 2005)

Good or great or average ? I'm still not sure , some of the scenes are shot great and Cruise gives a good acting performance as does the great English actor Timothy Spall Billy Connolly plays himself and the Japanese actors are what I'd expect realistic .
But i have so many problems with the film too ,the ending well i don't think so , into the valley of death etc and the only survivor well there's a surprise.
But still on the positive u get carried with film's style and also that the Japanese speak,well Japanese has to be a positive.The action is shot well although perhaps the ninja weren't quite as well trained as you might expect .