Laughable

Rating: 4/10 (20 January 2004)

Well, during all the movie Samurais are depicted as a warriors' elite that studied and practised the art of war for centuries. Nevertheless we see that it's very easy for an American alcoholic to equal them in the art of katana handling in just some months of training (this samurais must be dumb, as they practise katana since they are children !!). What about tactics ? After centuries of continuous warfare, they need a foreigner to teach them to feign a retreat and then to counterattack. And what about the final scene in which the captain arrives just when the pact is being signed and the Emperor changes idea ? I laughed to tears. I thought The Gladiator was unrivalled, but Hollywood never cease to amaze me. I'll seek comfort in Kagemusha or Gohatto.