Bushido

Rating: 10/10 (27 December 2019)

Edward Zwick is one of the most under-rated directors out there, but I don't feel this is entirely representative of his best work. Not to say it isn't a damn good film (it is), but it's plainly obvious that Hollywood had their hands on this.
The tone is inconsistent. One minute, there's a standard, generic Hollywood action scene, shot the same way all standard, generic Hollywood action scenes are shot. The next minute, however, is a very calm, still, introspective montage taken straight from Terrence Malick's playbook. If the movie was either a drama or an action film instead of trying to be both, I think it would have more of an identity. The pandering to the lowest-common-denominator viewer played a large role in preventing that from happening. Some moments feel overly simplified to the point where it almost becomes a detriment to the integrity of the subject matter. Zwick's touch was not entirely obscured; there are plenty of great shots, scenes, and moments that can only be the product of a film-maker of his caliber.
The story is not without flaw. The entire set-up is very plain and not all that interesting. The hero lacks motivation, purpose for his goal, has nothing at stake, etc. But once Katsumoto enters the picture, the movie takes a major turn for the better. Even though the hero is not doing much externally for a preponderance of the film, it still captivates due to the strength of his inner journey. Seeing Algren learn about the samurai culture and grow to understand and respect them is without question the movie's biggest strength. His gradual character arc is splendid to behold.
Cruise, however, was not a good choice for the role. He did the best job he could (a very good job, in truth), but he still felt entirely anachronistic; he didn't look, sound, or feel like a man from that era whatsoever.
A few lax passages early on and several others sprinkled around the second half certainly hold the film back from reaching its full potential. There is a truly great movie in there just waiting to get out. If only Hollywood would just let film-makers make films.
Despite their efforts and the flaws contained within, Zwick managed to come away with a quality product that is both meaningful and enjoyable. With more dedication to the film itself and less concern on how many people will go to the theater and spend money, this could have been a masterpiece on par with Glory.
PS: the musical score is absolutely fantastic.