I expected more

Rating: 6/10 (13 November 2008)

This film had great reviews. I had heard it being called the years favourite magician movie. This coming in the same year as Christopher Nolan's fantastic "The Prestige" came as very high praise. It had Edward Norton and Paul Giamatti in it so that just improved the excitement level.
It was mediocre. The plot was alright but i just felt a little disappointed. The film lacked punch. Giamatti was pretty good as the Inspector but what i was most disappointed with was Norton, on cruise control throughout the entire film. I've read other people say he's mesmerizing and fantastic. He's not. Compared to American History X and Fight Club, this is a very reserved performance. Just because he has an accent doesn't mean its a masterful performance. Its average. As is the film.
Its an enjoyable watch. But not enjoyable enough to be a romp. Its good, but no way near good enough for award recognition. Don't expect too much and you won't be disappointed.