An absolutely splendid story

Rating: 9/10 (3 October 2006)

One of the overall finest movies in years, this story has all of the elements of an Oscar winning film. Since the only special effects in the movie are contained in the illusions themselves, this production stands on its own merits without the need of the extra sensations, and the bells and whistles that move most of todays cinematic efforts.
The ensemble acting, and in fact all of the scenes, are top quality. The sequences are all essential and meaningful parts combining to make a greater finished product. Attention to the ambiance of the era, costume and design, lighting, and especially the direction make for an excellent production. Very engrossing, and very entertaining.
Norton is, as always, engaging and skillful in his character. Eisenheim is more polished, more mature, caring, and powerful than is Norton's more common character role of Mr. Nasty. In this story, Norton does exceptionally well as the one being accused and victimized, while all the while remaining a gentleman, as opposed to being the one usually doing the victimizing in other portrayals. Likewise, we see very convincing portrayals from police chief Giamatti, Crown Prince Sewell, and romantic interest Biel. (And isn't she gorgeous in this role?).
At the ending of the story, even though the twist is just a little bit predictable, it is done with such polish that no one really cares and just applauds. The highlight of the production, as in all successful endeavors, is the combined effort of the entire company, the directorship, the technical crew, and the period research. Will there be a sequel? We hope so.