Illusionist casts a nice spell

Rating: 9/10 (24 January 2007)

How bizarre, that two films centered on the mystery of magic and the timelessness of love situated in similar eras with a love triangle at the centre, would come out in the same year. Both films starring talented casts, no less. I speak of The Prestige and this film, The Illusionist.
For as much as The Prestige was as puzzling a film as this one, both are relatively easy to figure out with a keen view and knowledge of film or storytelling. Perhaps this is where the similarities must end, and comparisons no longer be drawn, because as I see it, The Illusionist is centered around a pure love story, Romeo and Juliet style, where no force can keep the loves separated. By contrast, The Prestige is about the relationship between two men who just can't seem to quit each other (not in the Brokeback Mountain sense) or let bygones be bygones, letting their professional quarrels spill over into their personal lives.
So, if inseparable love and undying passion is your cup of tea, then The Illusionist will fill your cup. Norton and Biel play their emotions beautifully, and Giamatti and Sewell continue their quest to be considered the best supporting actors in Hollywood. It's no secret that this film enjoys the better cast. Yet it keeps its secrets, unlike the foretelling found in the aforementioned film of similar theme and setting.
Norton really carries this piece, adding another top notch performance to his amazing resume. He comes across as vulnerable, yet powerful, a necessary trait for a star crossed lover facing opposition from the authorities and upper class. The movie's time and setting allow the film to draw out its key conflict, as Sewell and Giamatti must engage in a civil, cordial cat and mouse game with Norton, so as not to embarrass or misrepresent themselves. I can't imagine this same conflict in modern times, as a good pistol whipping or other gun play would solve this film in a quarter of an hour.
The Illusionist is not full of tricks, twists and shocking surprises. Instead, it mesmerizes you with sharp wit, sweet thoughts and stunning visuals that situate love where it belongs: out of this world.
Grade: A-