Masterful Characterizations, Excellent Atmosphere

Rating: Null/10 (3 March 2005)

The story in "The Hustler" is quite interesting in itself, but it is the characterizations and the atmosphere that make it so good. The characterizations are masterful, and the acting makes all of the characters believable and lifelike. Paul Newman, Jackie Gleason, and George C. Scott could not have been better, and they are joined by a fine supporting cast. The atmosphere likewise is excellent, forming a fine complement to the characters and their story.
Eddie, Minnesota, and Bert are all quite interesting in themselves, and the three characters also make for some nice comparisons and contrasts with each other. As the young pool star Eddie, Newman very effectively portrays the strengths and weaknesses that come with his great ability and self-confidence. As the old pro Minnesota, Gleason gets fewer opportunities, but he delivers flawlessly. He's a great character, and even though the movie is not really about him, he leaves you wanting to see more of him. The first, lengthy battle between Eddie and Minnesota is one of the fine set pieces of its era in cinema.
Scott's character is thoroughly unlikable, but undeniably intriguing, and Scott's distinctive style is perfect for the role. The supporting cast, likewise, features some effective character actors who make the best of their roles.
The story slows down considerably in the middle, as Piper Laurie's character comes onto the scene, but the change of pace is important in understanding Eddie and the things that lie ahead for him. Laurie's role is sometimes thankless compared with Newman's, but her character is an important contrast to Bert (Scott) and the way of life that Bert wants to offer Eddie. There are numerous somber yet important moments as everything plays out.
Naturally, the most fun parts of the movie are the pool-playing scenes, and they work even better than you could have hoped for. The atmosphere makes you feel as if you were there watching the action, and the musical score is surprisingly helpful in complementing the settings. Everything fits together well to make "The Hustler" a worthwhile classic.