Lighthearted fun, some flaws

Rating: 5/10 (5 May 2007)

A romantic comedy with an creative slant, involving two women who have recently broken off nightmare relationships, and want to get away from it all as far away from it all as they can get. One lives in England, the other in California, and they agree to swap houses for their respective vacations over the internet. It's a cute idea, and for the most part, it works. Since the women have both sworn off men for a while, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to guess the first thing that happens when each arrives at the other's home. The story line in England was the better scripted of the two, perhaps because the California story is burdened with some Hollyweird entertainment industry stereotypes.
The story was apparently written with these very actors in mind, but oddly enough, the casting turns out to be the film's biggest liability. Jack Black was in mind for this role? Somebody was out of their mind to use a guy who has only succeeded in cartoonish simpleton roles in the past. He's clearly out of place here, and even looks uncomfortable, managing only a goofy grin all the time. Cameron Diaz is a weak link too: she's always pulling her hair, making (outdated) Valley girl shrieking noises, or whining. These quirks are not original or amusing; they're just distracting.
On the other hand, Kate Winslett is the film's greatest strength, approaching her role with the lighthearted breeziness that is intended. Her character is easy to love, and some of the banter with veteran actor Eli Wallach as her curmudgeonly neighbor is a fun and interesting highlight.
In summary, a romantic comedy that has moments, but is marred somewhat by questionable casting. Good enough for a Saturday afternoon rental.