a bit self-indulgent

Rating: 6/10 (15 January 2013)

Let me start by saying The Hobbit was casted incredibly well. Martin Freeman was the perfect Bilbo, mostly due to his comedic timing with a good balance of heart as well (similar to Pipin & Merry in LOTR) that would have made the film to heavy otherwise. Gandalf played by the always fantastic Ian Mckellan is able to shine comedically as well, being the occasionally ambiguous (trickesy hobbitses!) and light hearted Gandalf the Gray we all loved from The Fellowship. New guy Richard Armitage as Thorin the dwarf, is featured heavily and has to carry the film at points. Armitage has had the hard task of making his character likable, without using humor (Bilbo does steal the show in that respect). The other 12 (is it 13) dwarfs are handled very well considering there are so many of them, you take away a few characteristics and quirks from all of them, that do add to the humor of the story as well. Andy Serkis is able to once again able to channel Gollum's comedic and tragic identity seemingly without effort.
The cinematography is as beautiful as it always is. If any movie wanted to make you travel to New Zealand this would be the one. As far as the frames per minute (some people feel as if they are watching a soap opera) as long as you have an HD t.v and you are used to it, the frames per minute shouldn't bother you too much. The 3D is a different story. Prepare yourself for some minor vertigo for some scenes. I am disappointed in Peter Jackson when it comes to he 3D it was completely unnecessary, and heavy handed. (If you want lessons on 3D go and see Hugo) The CGI was well done for the most part, but was heavy handed as well.
The Hobbit was a bit self indulgent, and probably would have been better in two parts, but overall it was a very satisfying film. From the ambitious action scenes to the comedic dialogue, The Hobbit will be sure to satisfy fans of the novel and action lovers as well.