Criticts were soooo wrong!

Rating: 10/10 (17 December 2012)

First time i write a review on a film... I am not a big fan of fantasy films, but since in Italy it was the only film which was opening in original language me and my wife decided to go. I told to her if it is as bad as critics say we will have at least 3 hours of good sleep...
And then those 3 hours finished i was like: What? it has ended! i want some more, please continue!!! Contains a small portion of spoilers...
1. Critics were wrong (my opinion) telling that it is too long. Maybe you could take out some 10-15 min of the movie but not more if you want to keep up with the book. so i think general idea of the 3 films is good. The 3 things director added to the original book script only gives additional depth to the film as THE director tries to show that the main story is just an episode of a bigger, darker picture and characters behind it who still haven't reveled themselves, but you can start guessing who will be the villain in the meeting at Rivendell. So personally to me it didn't fell too long at all. And i don't count other peoples money especially if these money are made by pure talent.
2. Critics are not fair enough telling that the movie is much worse then LOTR. Yes it is different, it still misses human presence, which remove some of the depth. But IT IS BASED ON A BOOK so i think the only way you can judge the film is if the production team perfectly revealed the book contents in the film or not. You cant make Shindlers list out of Hobbit if you are doing a movie based on Hobbit book. And to my opinion the production team just perfectly captures the story, do not skip any details from the film and the parts they add only brings it closer to the LOTR movie epics.
All in all 10/10. Good acting. Perfect talented cast. Not boring action film. I liked special effects - didn't look unnatural (i've watched in 2D though). The sound... they use the same theme music, but its so nice i don't mind!