Pretty good, but not the best it could have been

Rating: 7/10 (19 June 2008)

I would give it a 6 and 1/2, but I just gave it a seven. the reason I think I enjoyed this more than most people is because, I'm a fan of Mark Walhburg!I respect and love him and his work! I agree with a lot people when they talk about him getting into the role of Elliot.Mark's used to doing characters that are tough, this character's more laid back, gentle, and an all around sweet, appreciative, smart guy. So Mark really needed to try and practice hard to nail this role, So it's kinda hard to look at him differently, But all in all, he pulled it off, Not extremely good, but good, I could tell the hard work, and even though his characters are tough, they have a heart and caring side to them, which made it believable for playing " Eliiot". All of the people that go to this movie expect being scared, But if you know "M. Night", you know his movies like "Signs", weren't that scary, he goes for a more supernatural, kinda mystery thriller, not scary movie.I liked it, because I'm a fan of supernatural movies, whether scary of not. But that's for people like me, who love movies to death, where they look and see they idea's and get into the art and appreciation of the characters, there backgrounds, and can see where they're'e going. I could connect with them,especially Mark's. I'm also a sucker for romance though into this kinda movie, so I loved how in they end, the couple loved each other so much, they realized, how much they needed each other, and sacrificed themselves to be with each other.so for you movie buffs, who just like supernatural , and mystery, go see this movie.Expect to be creeped out, but not scared.