Better than the 1974 version

Rating: 7/10 (2 March 2014)

Good adaptation of the F Scott Fitzgerald book, and better than the 1974 adaptation. Not great though: too much style instead of substance (which has always been an issue with Baz Luhrmann's movies). The first half was mostly just Luhrmann showing off what he can do with special effects, light, colour and movement. The 21st-century soundtrack in a 1920s setting was particularly irritating.
However, the substance kicks-in in the second half, and then the movie becomes interesting. Much less special effects, much more drama. The last few scenes are very emotional, and brilliant.
I know this is supposed to be Leonardo DiCaprio's best shot at a Best Leading Actor Oscar, after being snubbed many times, but I don't see him getting it. I wouldn't even have him among the nominees. His performance is OK, but not brilliant. In fact, it is debatable whether he even deserves top billing in the movie. Yes, he plays the character after whom the movie is named, but Tobey Maguire has much more screen time.
Maguire puts in a solid performance, in a role which requires him to be solid but not spectacular. He is the narrator, and our eyes into the life of Gatsby and friends, not a man of action.
Carey Mulligan shines as Daisy. She is perfect for the role.
Good performances from an all-Australian supporting cast: Joel Edgerton, Isla Fisher, Jason Clarke, Jack Thompson and Elizabeth Debicki.