One of my favorite movies this year.

Rating: Null/10 (25 August 2004)

While some of the plot twists seemed a little strange, I really enjoyed this movie. Slight distractions from the main plot were evident but not overbearing to me.
Luke Greenfield really brought together an unconventional and inspiring love story.
I cheered for Emile Hirsch - the underdog, the nice guy, as he found himself learning to truly live for the first time. He brought credibility to the role of Matthew that I'm not sure anybody else could have pulled off.
Elisha Cuthbert was absolutely amazing. I saw this movie twice, and I'll probably see it again, because Elisha Cuthbert turned an extremely difficult role into the pivot that keeps this movie turning. Acting so good, she made me fall in love with the girl next door.
An outstanding supporting cast rounds out the movie to keep things interesting.
If you're looking for a serious movie or something to make you think- this isn't the one. But if you want a movie to remind you of best friends, first loves, forever loves, and just plain fun - you've got to see this movie.