enjoyable to watch, feelgoody, punchless, fare

Rating: 6/10 (19 March 2011)

Loosely based on the true story of Micky Ward, this movie ignores the genuine toughness, mental and physical strength, and immense perseverance necessary to become a champion boxer. Instead, it focuses on the family drama surrounding the fighter, as he endeavors to become his own person and emerge from the shadow of his older brother, himself a noted fighter.
The actors do nothing extraordinary: Melissa Leo renders her standard blue-collar, momma grizzly, Christian Bale essentially mimics the real-life Dick Eklund, and Mark Wahlberg plays himself, as usual, with his casual and likable reserve. The movie is missing what Micky Ward actually had, a punch. It portrays a triumph, without showing the real sacrifices -- physical pain, gruelling training -- necessary to get there. It feels unearned, and fake, and a discredit to Mr. Ward and any other champion.
A redeeming feature of the film, however, is that it reminds me of another that could be considered similar, but which is much more representative of reality in and outside the ring. That movie is "The Wrestler." Not based on a real life story, the lead actor there is able to create a memorable character which is a tribute to the craft of screen acting, and also to the American spirit. That film I recommend highly. You'll remember it. This one: you'll just feel good without wondering why.