Not all Americans hated this beautiful film!

Rating: 10/10 (20 March 1999)

I felt that I needed to add a comment as the Americans almost universally panned this film. When I first saw the film in the fall of '96, I felt overwhelmed by what seemed to be a convoluted plot with too many shallow characters. Having watched the film twice since then, however, I have come to appreciate the poetic dialogue as well as the amazing cinematography and score.
For me, Hana was the most sympathetic character in the film, marvelously portrayed by Juliette Binoche. Her spontaneity, beauty, and passion illuminate the screen like no other actress today in such films as "Bleu" and "Damage". During "The English Patient", she is the character I weep for as everyone she loves is tragically taken from her and yet, she still musters the courage to persevere.
This is definitely one of those films that is too complex to comprehend in one viewing. Because of this, I sincerely understand why many think it is overwrought and pretentious. Therefore, I am reserved in recommending it to everyone. The film is similar to "The Piano", another film that critics loved but that many viewers disliked for the same above-listed reasons. For those who do have the patience, however, a lush romantic story (with heart-warming quotations you will not soon forget), is a wonderful reward.