Hard to Critique.

Rating: Null/10 (4 July 2002)

David Lynch's unorthodox direction (Oscar-nominated) and the highly dark black-and-white cinematography are the main attractions in this over-rated would-be-masterpiece. A circus freak with Proteus Syndrome (Oscar nominee John Hurt) is living a life that is much like a wild animal's, but in spite of his appearance he is a sensitive and very intelligent man. Victorian doctor Anthony Hopkins tries to save him from a life of misery. The film struggles for greatness and almost succeeds, but the movie's odd tone does not help its case in the end. Anne Bancroft and John Gielgud seem wasted in supporting roles. Good, but far from being excellent. Still one of Lynch's most interesting works. 4 stars out of 5.