i don't think this is a great movie. as said by many.

Rating: 4/10 (14 February 2007)

The movie is rushed and parts unexplained in the end, which leaves my experience unsatisfied. So the movie makes a dud for me. i don't understand how so many praises can be made for this movie , When it is a copy of a wholesome movie with scenes and dialogs copied to no avail. i would say that people have not understood or they normally don't enjoy the whole movie and they just like parts of it. or maybe people have just seen the movie because of the love for Martin Scorsese, who has been a great name in the film making world and delivered some of the most moving and realistic movies made up to date. But this was not what i was expecting from him. Loyalty has been a bias in many of the reviews of this rushed and inconclusive movie.