Not as good as Infernal Affairs

Rating: 6/10 (8 October 2006)

Having seen Infernal Affairs, I had expectations that were perhaps unrealistic. The 2002 film from Hong Kong had action and depth. The writers of The Departed took an excellent story and expanded it. The additions made added nothing to the story, in fact they detracted from the main characters' struggles. The expansion of the mob boss character only served to highlight Jack Nicholson. While I enjoy Jack as much as the next person, the story is more about Costigan and Sullivan and their struggle with each other and their own demons. I will admit that the acting was very good. Unfortunately, a great cast does not necessarily mean a great movie. Scorsese was over the top in terms of the violence and side stories. All in all, I was very disappointed. I expect American audiences will be pleased enough.