Another Superb Film from the Maestro of the Mob Movie

Rating: 10/10 (12 May 2007)

Family is at the center of any Scorsese mob film, and it is no different here. Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCarprio) and Colin Sullivan (Matt Damon) are two young men with little family remaining except for the father figure who serves as the center of each of their worlds; Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson), the head of the Irish Mafia in Boston. But they have gotten to their mutual destination via different routes. Colin was orphaned and living with his grandparents when Costello took the young man under his wings. Morally ambiguous, but with a lust for power of his own, Colin graduates with honors from the Massachusetts State Police Academy, and is soon a detective in the Special Investigations Unit, a perfect place for him to tip off his benefactor Costello on all police activity.
Billy is sent to prison for three months for assault to establish his credentials, then sets up operations back in South Boston, soon attracting the attention of Costello via his main henchman, the sadistic Mr. French (Ray Winstone). Having no sons of his own, Costello seems to always be on the lookout for another protégé, and after an extremely violent confrontation with Billy to ensure his motives; he befriends the young man, and puts him to work for his crew.
Eventually, both sides become aware of a mole in their midst, and the race is on to see who will be first to eliminate their problem. Betrayals and other twists further complicate issues until the inevitable series of final gut-wrenching, ultra-violent confrontations take this movie to an even higher level.
But unlike a good caper film, the soul of the movie is not in the events themselves, but in the reactions of the characters to them. In this case, Scorsese gets Oscar worthy performances from all five of his lead actors. In smaller roles, Sheen and Wahlberg are a terrific tandem as the only men who know of Billy's identity. Sheen is much different from his elitist Jed Bartlett character on "The West Wing"; paternal and kind with a strong lower middle-class work ethic and understated resolve. Wahlberg is his emotional polar opposite; a firebrand who takes no prisoners in dealing with anyone else and is wound so tightly that he might explode at any minute.
Although Nicholson is the most prominent star, the movie is carried by virtuoso performances from Damon and DiCaprio. Damon has leveraged his charms, good looks, and boy-next-door appeal into a very nice career as a leading man and Action Hero. So it takes an actor with a great deal of confidence in himself and his director to skewer those traits into a character that is not at all sympathetic. He has done it before with his performance in "Syriana", but he takes it to a much higher level here. You do not ever really feel for Colin, and you want him to get caught. But at the same time, he is not a typical two-dimensional villain, and Damon does a fantastic job showing you the insides of a man who has lost his moral compass, but is still conflicted about his dual identities nonetheless, and is uncomfortable with that conflict. He is a compulsive, natural liar, but is genuinely hurt when his lies cause emotional pain to his girlfriend.
Leonardo DiCaprio, like Damon, is evolving into one of the best young actors on screen today. Reviled by many for his boyish appearance and his turn in "Titanic", Leo's recent path has become the complete opposite of Ben Affleck's career over the last several years. While Affleck parlayed his good looks into weak "star vehicle" bombs like "Paycheck", "Daredevil", and "Gigli", DiCaprio has sought out complex, untraditional roles not normally associated with "pretty boys". Perhaps his biggest stroke of luck was in landing the lead role in Scorsese's "Gangs of New York", as his performance in that underrated film impressed Scorsese so much that he has cast him in the lead for "The Aviator" and "The Departed".
In this case, DiCaprio far exceeds the impressive performance he gave as the reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes, and creates a character that will be remembered for generations, much like Ray Liotta's Henry Hill in "Goodfellas". He is simply gripping as Billy Costigan, and any time he is on screen, you are concerned for his well being, and empathetic towards the mental and physical price Billy is paying for his duplicity. Billy has two disadvantages in his charade when compared to Colin. The first being that the danger he faces is far greater as the people he is spying on are much more ruthless than the police. The other is that Billy truly does have a conscience, in contrast to the ethically challenged Colin, and the guilt and stress are slowly tearing him apart, a fact that is evident in every frame featuring DiCaprio.
10/10 good film