Echo's of Independence Day

Rating: 8/10 (27 May 2004)

I bet Emmerich and chums thought they had hit the jackpot when they decided to make a film on global warming: the first to do so to my knowledge. And, it is the idea or the notion of these terrible events actually occurring, in our own life times that keep you glued to the screen in this interesting, special effects driven thriller.
It really is a tale of two films; the first and the second half. The first half builds up the tension with the use of news reports, political conferences and some amazing special effects (the tornadoes in L.A). It feels like Independence Day, Emmerichs other blockbuster in the way that it cranks up the tension to such a degree that it can only leave you disappointed with the climax. I'm not saying however that the second half, Jack Hall (Quaid) going off to rescue his son (Gyllenhaal), is a load of rubbish but after the engrossing and possibly overlong introduction its a bit of a let down.
The recuse mission is to short. There are not enough thrills and spills to make it exciting enough; Jack finds his son to easily and the relationship between Sam (Gyllenhaal) and Laura (Rossum) is not developed enough to be believable.
In conclusion we have solid performances all round with no-one particularly excelling in their roles (Rossum is charmingly sweet none the less) and a strong background story (aided by amazing CGI work) coupled with weak human drama. Emmerich's given use another slice of popcorn cinema but like Independence Day its a film of two halves.
Bernard L Black gives it: 7/10 for a strong and compelling first and second act supported by jaw dropping CGI storms and tornadoes. The third act just didn't have enough action and the emotional payoff the first two deserved.