Great idea, but rather poor result

Rating: 7/10 (4 August 2004)

I liked the idea for this movie.. all though it's been mentioned before.
I'll make this short..
Great special effects and all, rather nice visuals. But I have some points that was REALLY stupid.. in my opinion.

1st. The WOLF SCENE on the boat, what was that all about???? Shouldn't made it to the final cut, if you ask me (but who did?) - 2nd. Why do they burn books, instead of wood from the furniture. Wood produces more heat than paper, lasts longer and so on.. - 3rd. It's been snowing and freezing for days in New York, and still Jack Hall sees the people (from the library) dead in the snow. There should be literally meters of snow on top of those corpses.

All in all Great idea, but rather poor result.. this film could have been SO, SO much better. I just had to let it out.. There I'm all better now, thnx!!
Luke_