Over-rated?

Rating: 7/10 (12 November 2008)

This film was met with a lot of anticipation, not just by fans of the superhero genre, but by fans of film in general, the iconic symbol of Batman instantly recognisable in our culture. Expectations were risen by the critical and commercial success of Batman Begins, which effectively added a gritty realism that was a long shot away from the camp and half-hearted Batman of the 90s.
However, despite the anticipation and hype surrounding this film, was it really worth it? Where the first film offered us a refreshing perspective on Batman and offered some illuminating social criticism, as well as an engaging plot, the new batman appears inferior in almost every aspect apart from excess marketing.
I feel this was a good opportunity, with a great cast and director to offer us something more. But apart from the action packed thrills and undoubtedly spectacular shots of Gotham City, this remains a thin film without the engaging plot and message of its predecessor.
The message of Batman Begins was distinguishing between justice and revenge, but the sequel appears to say that loss of human rights and the use of violence is OK in order to protect people. A much less appealing moral in my opinion.
The other shame is that the late Heath Ledger, an actor with such enormous potential, was ridiculously tipped for an Oscar. The performance is carried with great verve, but only to the extent that the shallow script allowed. As an admirer of the actor, I would like to see him win an Oscar, but for him to win one for the joker would be unjust. A much more interesting character in my opinion, as well as integral to the plot of the film, was Harvey Dent. Although his decline is a little too sudden and complete, the development is dramatic, plus Eckhart was perfectly casted for the role.
In conclusion, I do not want to be too harsh to The Dark Knight, as it was not a bad film. I thought it was a decent film, but did not earn its hype, nor was it as good as its predecessor. A recommended viewing, but I wanted to add some perspective to the unremitting praise this film has received.