Good, but far from the #1 movie of all-time

Rating: 7/10 (22 July 2008)

I don't normally comment on films on this site, but when I saw that this movie was rated by users as the #1 movie of all-time, I had to set the record straight.
Yes, while this is a good movie with great cinematography and a great performance by the late Heath Ledger, it is far from being the #1 movie of all-time. It is not even the #1 movie of the summer (Iron Man, for one, was better). Nor is it the best movie in the series (Batman Begins is better). There are plot holes galore and the chemistry between Maggie Gyllenhall's character and Batman/Wayne and Dent is simply lacking.
Those who rate this movie #1 all-time clearly have not seen Raging Bull, Clockwork Orange, Rear Window, Casablanca or any number of other all-time great films. This movie should not even be in the top 200 all-time.
Good...but not the "masterpiece" other users suggest it is.