good

Rating: 8/10 (18 July 2006)

I don't get why everybody says this is such a bad movie. I mean, it wasn't the best movie ever but I quit liked it. Tom Hanks and Ian McKellen are doing great, is usual and I won't say anything about Tautu because I really can't stand her. She did well in this movie but we had to watch 'Amelie Poulain' a few years ago and then make a test and I think I got some sort of trauma about her :-). I read the book, so I saw that some parts weren't exactly the same as in the novel. But so what? Harry Potter movies are also not also the same and the audience still enjoys it. I think, but that's just my opinion, that people who really didn't like this movie are very conservative and if you wanted an exact copy from the book, why don't you does read the book again? Really, a good film for everybody who is a bit open minded.