mixed blessings

Rating: Null/10 (9 July 2003)

It is really difficult to look objectively at this key moment in movie history, almost 90 years down the line.
Griffith's greatest achievement has to be seen in its historical context to understand its lauding of the Ku Klux Klan; here was someone who saw the Civil War and the movements within it with glory and affection, and who undoubtedly had very different values to today's viewers. This gives rise to what can only be described as a flawed view of the race question in America. However, I don't think that gives modern filmmakers the right to change or tamper with Griffith's vision. It must be left to stand as it is, faults and all.
Performance-wise, we have Lilian Gish and Mae Marsh, both perennials for Griffith, and both excellent, and the great Henry B Walthall, plus an entertaining short appearance from Joseph Hanabery as Lincoln. There's also a small, showpiece role for the young Wallace Reid (as the blacksmith). We have sweeping vistas of battles both in war and outside, we have imagination, scope, and energy not seen in films made prior to BOAN's appearance. Yes, the politics are suspect - but this is film history, it is our heritage, and for that reason alone, BOAN has to be recognised for the great milestone it was and the influence it undoubtedly had on movies that followed.