Most critically underrated movie of the year....

Rating: 8/10 (13 November 2007)

This film is as close to perfection as it gets. I'm completely baffled by those who do not get it. But then again, they are probably baffled by why I don't understand how movies like "National Treasure" sell more than twelve tickets.
I read a review about how only "cinemaphiles" will get this movie. Uhhh, well, uhhhh, yes I agree.
First of all, the cinematography is breathtaking. And the acting is outstanding. And you don't get all this without amazing direction. Brad Pitt delivers his best, by far, performance to date. I wish he would stick to meatier roles like this and stop than Oceans 11 (12, 13, 245) nonsense. And Casey Affleck actually gave me the chills, his performance is so dead-on. As terrific as Brad Pitt is, this is Casey Affleck's movie. His performance is chilling - and haunting. And he nails this character. If he does not get an Oscar nomination, I will take a hostage. In addition, Sam Rockwell gives one of the most likable and entertaining performances I've seen in a while. His timing is impeccable. (That scene on the ice where Jesse keeps firing his gun and Rockwell keeps continuing the conversation made me laugh out loud.) All the supporting characters are amazing. And we have the bonus of Sam Shephard. If you like good acting, this film is like the motherload. Too bad they didn't let Mary Louise Parker speak more than 3 words.
One thing I haven't heard too many people comment on is the dark humor in this film. I laughed out loud several times. Luckily, I wasn't the only one. Usually I'm getting the "something is wrong with that woman" look as I'm laughing at the dark, hidden humor in films such as "Sling Blade" and The Assassination of Jesse James. Maybe its a southern thing.
The ONLY criticism I have of this movie is the somewhat distracting voice-over narration. This kind of bugged me. Sounded like someone narrating a children's fable. With this kind of acting, we don't need someone telling us what is taking place.
I hope Brad Pitt gets an Oscar nomination for Lead Actor (although he is not the actual lead, Casey Affleck is but Brad Pitt is considered the Lead). And I not only hope that Casey Affleck gets an Oscar nomination for supporting actor, I hope he takes the gold fellow home.