A few words sez it all in this gem.

Rating: 9/10 (23 November 2011)

Tired of big budget effects driven movies? Had your fill of dialogue driven movies that seem like plays? Do you long for the simpler days of stories set in Hollywood complete with Hollywood endings?
The premise is "A Star Is Born" but it's the flawless execution that makes this movie a unique joy. It's in high contrast Black and White, with almost no dialogue, presented in a retro aspect ratio.
The stars, Jean Dujardin and Berenice Bejo, not well known in the USA, are outstanding. Bejo lights up the screen and is sure to garner a Best Supporting Actress nomination. The supporting cast includes more familiar faces. The dog is terrific.
Cinematography awards were previously divided into color and black & white, here it's perfect black & white. The score is a homage to movie music of the past and works to maintain the mood. There is interesting use of sound when needed.
Perhaps silent films were grainier and exhibition prints may have had change-over cues missing from this pristine digital replica. Nitrate film probable burns more intensely then shown on screen.
The movie has drama, humor and charm. If you love the golden age of Hollywood you will love this movie. It will be among the most talked about movies of the year and will be included on most ten best lists. See it.